Mayweather will be considered #1 of alltime

[Nwahs !!]

That wouldn't even put him above Pernell Whitaker.

[IMDAZED]

If he beats Dela hoya, Hatton, Mosley, Margarito, Cotto, Karmazin, Ouma, Wright...and retires undefeated at middleweight

with a record of 44-0, Undefeated


Just tell me where would u consider him in the alltime list? alltime boxer list...


please dont troll here, just discuss if this does happen where would you have him in your all time list just put a number up.

for me its a top 3 alltime...near robinson and ali

Umm...can you tell me what Oscar's record is the past five years? Not exactly a "big" victory. Neither, I might add, is beating the likes of Ouma and Karmazin. How about we just wait for him to clean out the welterweight division?

[2501]

top 15 right now, if he were to defeat 2 more legit top welters, i could see him in the top 10 but he would never been considered in the top 5.

[Flab]

If he beats Cotto he would be #1 P4P greatest.

[THE REED]

i truthfully believe nobody will ever conquer SRR

120 some fights agains the absolute best

they just dont fight that often anymore

[Parody]

Umm...can you tell me what Oscar's record is the past five years? Not exactly a "big" victory. Neither, I might add, is beating the likes of Ouma and Karmazin. How about we just wait for him to clean out the welterweight division?

Did you realise I created this threads 2 years back? When Oscar and Hatton were "threats", when they got beaten people started talking **** about both of them.

[Flab]

James Toney did.

[THE REED]

If he beats Cotto he would be #1 P4P greatest.

what the hell? cotto beat zab mental block judah and a 36 yr old mosley? now cotto can certifiy someone as the greatest by beating him?

floyd doesnt need cotto... cotto needs floyd... and now hes fighting alfonso gomez?

cotto isnt MAKING anyones career... not yet anyway.. not by a longshot

[BrooklynBomber]

Uhmm.....NO.

Not even close to that.

[IMDAZED]

Did you realise I created this threads 2 years back? When Oscar and Hatton were "threats", when they got beaten people started talking **** about both of them.

I fail to see your point. Again, what's Oscar's record the past five years? And while I didn't think Hatton was much of a threat, I never mentioned his name in my post - I believe I mentioned Ouma and Karmazin. So what's your point again?