Has Brook been doing a Canelo?

[TheBoxingXpert]

Has Brook been doing a Canelo? Has he in reality belonged to a higher weight class all along, while draining himself to get a size advantage?

[Dodger07]

I wish we could've seen him against some of the elite wws like Thurman, Bradley, Garcia, Spence etc before moving up. I still believe that moving up to mw against Ggg is a very drastic and potentially harmful career decision. But brook knows his body better than anyone else and he was massive at ww.

Speaking of Canelo I wouldn't mind a fight between him and brook tbh

[Luilun]

Who knows and who cares

[boliodogs]

He makes the ***ing weight and Canelo makes the ***ing weight. They are both obeying the rules so quit your b*tching. When Brook fought Porter he weighed 156 on fight night and that was slightly less than Porter weighed on fight night. A gain of 9 pounds from weigh in to fight isn't unusual so where is the size advantage you think Brook might have? When Canelo fought Trout I think he weighed 171 on fight night and Trout weighed 172 on fight night. Canelo gained about 17 pounds and that's a large gain but not unheard of. Canelo still weighed less than Trout so where was his weigh advantage? Why don't you start more positive threads instead of trashing good fighters with stuff like this?

[TheBoxingXpert]

He makes the ***ing weight and Canelo makes the ***ing weight. They are both obeying the rules so quit your b*tching. When Brook fought Porter he weighed 156 on fight night and that was slightly less than Porter weighed on fight night. A gain of 9 pounds from weigh in to fight isn't unusual so where is the size advantage you think Brook might have? When Canelo fought Trout I think he weighed 171 on fight night and Trout weighed 172 on fight night. Canelo gained about 17 pounds and that's a large gain but not unheard of. Canelo still weighed less than Trout so where was his weigh advantage? Why don't you start more positive threads instead of trashing good fighters with stuff like this?

They make the weight, but they're obviously doing it to get cheap advantages. There's a lot you don't seem to understand. Why is Canelo so focused on guys like Cotto, Khan and Smith from the lower weights?

[Zaryu]

No, I don't think Brook gains as much weight as Canelo from the weigh in to fight night.

[TheBoxingXpert]

No, I don't think Brook gains as much weight as Canelo from the weigh in to fight night.

No one does it like Canelo. That fat frickled albino mutant.

[RussB23]

Yea i think hes a JMW, just able to drain himself to make 147. Dude is a huge ww

[!! Shawn]

He makes the ***ing weight and Canelo makes the ***ing weight. They are both obeying the rules so quit your b*tching. When Brook fought Porter he weighed 156 on fight night and that was slightly less than Porter weighed on fight night. A gain of 9 pounds from weigh in to fight isn't unusual so where is the size advantage you think Brook might have? When Canelo fought Trout I think he weighed 171 on fight night and Trout weighed 172 on fight night. Canelo gained about 17 pounds and that's a large gain but not unheard of. Canelo still weighed less than Trout so where was his weigh advantage? Why don't you start more positive threads instead of trashing good fighters with stuff like this?

He might have also been starving himself at all times to stay down at that weight, much like hopkins did for years to stay at 160. Then he filled into a natural 175 like it was where he should have been all along.

From the way Brooks body looked in the 170's, I have a feeling that this is the first fight he has been able to eat, and his body is growing to the size that it naturally wants to be.

[TheBoxingXpert]

He might have also been starving himself at all times to stay down at that weight, much like hopkins did for years to stay at 160. Then he filled into a natural 175 like it was where he should have been all along.

From the way Brooks body looked in the 170's, I have a feeling that this is the first fight he has been able to eat, and his body is growing to the size that it naturally wants to be.

A man with reason can only agree to that.