should the fat ***** retire?

[Double]

If, and I hope it's not a BIG if, If he can get in shape for 2-3 more fights he'll give any HW a run for their money and probaly beats 99% of them. Again I said "IF"

[Double]

i think he should fight until it is clear who is the HW Champ ...

although another loss, he should consider retiring Healty ...

Let's keep this in mind, he has yet to lose (officially) as a heavyweight, and he's fought 2 of the alphabet champs. i think thye Rahman draw was a wake up call and we'll see the best the 39 year old Toney has to ofer in his next fight.

[Manny_P]

he shouldn't retire. As a 'fat' heavyweight, no one has even beaten him up yet. Imagine if he decides to get healthy then. Besides, the heavyweight right now is weak and anybody can take it. It's like flipping a coin everytime there's a heavyweight fight.

[joeytrimble]

Calling James fat is one thing, calling him a ***** is another. Oh well, not standing infront of him I guess you guys can say what you want to.

James is still ok. He does need to get his conditioning up but he is as skilled a fighter as is out there. Granted he's slowed abit with age and injury but he is still one of the elite.

Rockin'

exactly! good call my brotha

try that ***** **** in front of toney he has a look that'd make a bear turn away

no way in bloody hell would i ever ever EVVVER never ever ever ever talk **** to james lights out toney...thats like pokeing a lion in the butt with a branding iron

[Xcel]

Nah, he shouldnt. I would love him to get in shape for his next fight tho.

[BKM-]

exactly! good call my brotha

try that ***** **** in front of toney he has a look that'd make a bear turn away

no way in bloody hell would i ever ever EVVVER never ever ever ever talk **** to james lights out toney...thats like pokeing a lion in the butt with a branding iron

You are right, but we have the right. I want to see him get beat up. I wont call him a ***** in real life, bad idea i guess

[joeytrimble]

yeah lol he could use some improveing or an asskicking

[hollister]

No one pays to see you defend punches, you're supposed to throw them in return

The Toney-Rahman fight isn't the only time you've seen Toney fight, right?

[K-DOGG]

Nah, he shouldnt. I would love him to get in shape for his next fight tho.

Your avatar!! Holy crap, I had that game! "Pro Wrestling"....that's the Amazon using a foreign object on Fighter Hayabusa!! TOO MUCH!!! LOL!!!

[ROSEWOOD]

WHY RETIRE. The HW class sucks now so that means its wide open. Hell he will fight until he is 60 because he is simply smarter than everyone else in his class.