Is Brook a good win for Golovkin?

[OnePunch]

OK, let's get this out of the way. How much credit so you give Golovkin should he beat Brook?

absolutely ZERO


Edit: Them only thing this fight does is to quiet the people who claim that Brook wont fight anyone with a pulse.

[gmc_rfc_06]

The funniest thing about this is seeing the blatant hypocrisy by some on this board. Bashing Canelo for taking Khan but accepting this bout wholeheartedly.

Khan went up 8lbs, Brook is going up 13lbs.

'It's ok though, Brook is undefeated.'

[PivotandRoll]

Did you have that same reaction when your GOD Floyd fought Marquez? Because it's the same thing.

GGG has been retired for two years and Brook is a multiple weight HOFer??? Why bother spout bull*****???

[therealpugilist]

OK, let's get this out of the way. How much credit so you give Golovkin should he beat Brook?

the sad part is the most recognizable names on his resume will be a shot Kassim Ouma and a welter titlist

this is pathetic.....p4p top 3 my azz

[boxinghead530]

GGG has been retired for two years and Brook is a multiple weight HOFer??? Why bother spout bull*****???

GTFOH, its the same thing. And floyd was only out a year and a half. But Floyd was still more of a fresh and prime younger fighter than GGG is now. So just stop it now.

I dont like this GGG fight just as much as i didnt like the Floyd-Marquez.

[Irony123]

that's what happens in the 11th hour of negotiations with 2 months left to make a fight. not a good fight at all, very little to no credit will be given from me but after trying to do a Canelo fight, BJS fight and Eubank fight with no success... i will come to terms with this fight.

[PivotandRoll]

GTFOH, its the same thing. And floyd was only out a year and a half. But Floyd was still more of a fresh and prime younger fighter than GGG is now. So just stop it now.

I dont like this GGG fight just as much as i didnt like the Floyd-Marquez.

Whatever hater, You brought up Floyd for no reason other than to take a pop. I clearly pointed out the huge differences.

Why not point out Duran jumping two weight classes to beat Sugar Ray Leonard??

[boxinghead530]

Whatever hater, You brought up Floyd for no reason other than to take a pop. I clearly pointed out the huge differences.

Why not point out Duran jumping two weight classes to beat Sugar Ray Leonard??

Did you read the thread headlines? It asks if Brook is a good win for GGG.

My response was its about as good of a win for GGG as Marquez is for Floyd?

So why you being the hater.

Dont act like one fight is good for you but another isnt, when both are the same.

[PivotandRoll]

Did you read the thread headlines? It asks if Brook is a good win for GGG.

My response was its about as good of a win for GGG as Marquez is for Floyd?

So why you being the hater.

Dont act like one fight is good for you but another isnt, when both are the same.

Floyd's win against Marquez is a splendid display of boxing against a true master that went on to prove his worth at the weight twice over, that you haters dismiss. My only problem with this fight is GGG's hypocrisy. First it was anyone 154-168. Then turns down Ward. Won't fight Canelo at 155 but admits he would fight Floyd at 154 and now brings Brook up from 147. I don't have a problem with the fight at all. I'll be supporting Brook as always.

[The Hammer]

Let's not forget, Floyd Mayweather's best win is over a faded former flyweight champion (actually started at straw weight) who moved all the way up to welterweight, namely Manny Pacquiao

He often fought opponents from smaller divisions (Ricky Hatton, Juan Manuel Marquez, etc)

Bernard Hopkins fought the much smaller former lightweight De La Hoya and former welterweight Trinidad, and those were regarded as good wins.