New welterweight rankings

[John Locke]

1. Brook
2. Thurman
3. Porter
4. Spence
5. Vasquez
6. Bradley
7. Garcia
8. Khan
9. Ponomarev
10. Vargas

What's everyone else got? You can easily switch Thurman and Brook around, Spence hasn't 'earned' a place in the top 5 yet, but based on skill, I think he may well be the top guy at 147.

[-PBP-]

1. Brook
2. Thurman
3. Porter
4. Spence
5. Vasquez
6. Bradley
7. Garcia
8. Khan
9. Ponomarev
10. Vargas

What's everyone else got? You can easily switch Thurman and Brook around, Spence hasn't 'earned' a place in the top 5 yet, but based on skill, I think he may well be the top guy at 147.

Thurman over Brook. Who has Brook beaten outside of Porter?

Zaveck, Chaves, and Guerrero were all top 10 fighters at some point.

[mlac]

Thurman over Brook. Who has Brook beaten outside of Porter?

Zaveck, Chaves, and Guerrero were all top 10 fighters at some point.

Yeah and not when he beat them.

[John Locke]

Thurman over Brook. Who has Brook beaten outside of Porter?

Zaveck, Chaves, and Guerrero were all top 10 fighters at some point.

Thurman definitely has a better resume than Brook, no question, but head to head, I would probably favour Brook, I think he might be a better fighter all-round. Not 100% sure though, we need to see more of both guys at the top level

[Dodger07]

Keith Thurman
Kell Brook
Shawn Porter
Tim Bradley
Danny Garcia
Amir Khan
Jessie Vargas
Errol Spence
Sammie Vazquez jr
Frankie Gomez

[soul_survivor]

1. Brook
2. Thurman
3. Porter
4. Spence
5. Vasquez
6. Bradley
7. Garcia
8. Khan
9. Ponomarev
10. Vargas

What's everyone else got? You can easily switch Thurman and Brook around, Spence hasn't 'earned' a place in the top 5 yet, but based on skill, I think he may well be the top guy at 147.

smh Bradley at 6? Burn this list

[Dr Rumack]

Thurman climbs above Porter but there's nothing else to say. I think we could be waiting a while for another clash of significance.

[HanzGruber]

Garcia should be three and Bradley 4.

[mathed]

1. Brook
2. Thurman
3. Porter
4. Spence
5. Vasquez
6. Bradley
7. Garcia
8. Khan
9. Ponomarev
10. Vargas

What's everyone else got? You can easily switch Thurman and Brook around, Spence hasn't 'earned' a place in the top 5 yet, but based on skill, I think he may well be the top guy at 147.

LOL, Spence, Porter and Vasquez over Bradley.

[LacedUp]

Thurman over Brook. Who has Brook beaten outside of Porter?

Zaveck, Chaves, and Guerrero were all top 10 fighters at some point.

So was senchenko & jackiwiecz.