Comments Thread For: Two New Arrivals: BoxingScene Pound-for-Pound Update

[Idunnoshet]

Andre Ward is higher up in the list even with being inactive for so long!!?
I like Andre but having him way up there in p4p list after almost 2yrs of inactivity isnt justified.. Also, there is no Tyson Fury in the list! I mean, c'mon now.. He is the lineal HW champ & he should be up there..

Fury is a couple spots outside my P4P list . I mean yeah he beat boring a** Klitschko . But he beat him in an even More boring fashion n has done sh't but run his mouth n eat since . Win the rematch = get ur spot on the list .

[cork]

I dont get the love fest with Gonzalez. He doesn't do anything special but maybe having a higher work rate than everyone else. Why does everyone have him #1? Someone point out to me what he does that's so special?

[BrometheusBob.]

I think this list is pretty solid

[BoxingFan85]

Fury is a couple spots outside my P4P list . I mean yeah he beat boring a** Klitschko . But he beat him in an even More boring fashion n has done sh't but run his mouth n eat since . Win the rematch = get ur spot on the list .

I respectfully disagree... If you are saying going the full distance & getting a W is enough getting the lineal belt but isn't enough to be on the P4P list, then I think the list aint worth to be on.. Can you justify Loma being above Rigo ?? Or Ward being above Rigo/Crawford ??

I try to evaluate the credit not as a fan, but as a person who should not be biased.. Heck, I don't even like Fury personally.. But he beat the man & he is the man of the division.. Like it or not..

[ShoulderRoll]

#5 is too high for Lomachenko at this point, in my opinion. I do see the skills though and if he keeps winning he will be a mainstay.

Lots of guys have better resumes. Danny Garcia for example. Is Rocky Martinez really that much better of a win than Robert Guerrero?

[aboutfkntime]

Andre Ward is higher up in the list even with being inactive for so long!!?
I like Andre but having him way up there in p4p list after almost 2yrs of inactivity isnt justified.. Also, there is no Tyson Fury in the list! I mean, c'mon now.. He is the lineal HW champ & he should be up there..

He fought TWICE since June 2015 you fkn clown.

About time you updated your weak excuses, foolio.

[aboutfkntime]

I respectfully disagree... If you are saying going the full distance & getting a W is enough getting the lineal belt but isn't enough to be on the P4P list, then I think the list aint worth to be on.. Can you justify Loma being above Rigo ?? Or Ward being above Rigo/Crawford ??

I try to evaluate the credit not as a fan, but as a person who should not be biased.. Heck, I don't even like Fury personally.. But he beat the man & he is the man of the division.. Like it or not..

You shouldn't even be here if you think that Crawford should be ranked ahead of Ward.

[BoxingFan85]

He fought TWICE since June 2015 you fkn clown.

About time you updated your weak excuses, foolio.

Oh you mean Mr. Paul No good Smith !?
After '13 he fought at a bloody CW against a nobody until he fought Barrera at LHW..

I like Dre, but I don't like his hooligan fans like you.. Time to draw your head out of Wards a$$ and see the world.. Gee.. Talk about butt hurt blind fanboys..

[BoxingFan85]

You shouldn't even be here if you think that Crawford should be ranked ahead of Ward.

Hate to say this Einstein but this is 2016 and not 2013.. So yeah, who you fight counts and how often you fight counts.. You can spin off your own logic for Ward to be there, not me.. As I said, I like the guy but you just cannot be on the list living by your legacy..

[koolbreez12]

I dont get the love fest with Gonzalez. He doesn't do anything special but maybe having a higher work rate than everyone else. Why does everyone have him #1? Someone point out to me what he does that's so special?

Ya I'm struggling to understand it as well. I mean he's really good, but I also see a lot of flaws. I have a hard time seeing what makes him consensus #1. Honestly I wasn't all the impressed with him against Arroyo, didn't look like a p4p #1 if you ask me.