Mayweather vs the fab four..

[1g5a22]

Prime Duran, Hearns, Hagler & SRL?

Prime Oscar, Mosley, Trinidad & Winky Wright?

FW versions of Pac, Barrera, Morales & JMM from the 00's?

How would he fare against these groups of great fighters at there peak? Would this type of rivalry have brought out the best or worst in Floyd? He lacks those great rivalries so I was wondering how you think he would have done..

I know he fought Pac, Oscar, Mosley & JMM but they were all mid 30's to 40 or well above there best weights.

[bluebeam]

Prime Duran, Hearns, Hagler & SRL?

Prime Oscar, Mosley, Trinidad & Winky Wright?

FW versions of Pac, Barrera, Morales & JMM from the 00's?

How would he fare against these groups of great fighters at there peak? Would this type of rivalry have brought out the best or worst in Floyd? He lacks those great rivalries so I was wondering how you think he would have done..

I know he fought Pac, Oscar, Mosley & JMM but they were all mid 30's to 40 or well above there best weights.

Floyd beats duran. Same Leonard gameplan.
Floyd vs Leonard is close
Floyd loses to hearns . Hitman jab would dominate the fight
floyd loses to hagler. Not too many atg middleweights I would pick floyd to beat


floyd beats pac. Pac doesn't adjust
Floyd beats barrera. Barrera would fare the best out of the mexicans
Floyd beats marquez. Juan will miss all night
Floyd beats morales. Erik fights with his emotions too much to win against floyd.

floyd beats mosley. Mosley can't handle boxers. Mosley's only chance is a ko. He can't win a decision aginst floyd.
Floyd ****s Trinidad. Tito can't dodge a jab
Floyd vs oscar is close
Floyd vs winky is close

[Robbie Barrett]

[Johnwoo8686]

Floyd beats duran. Same Leonard gameplan.
Floyd vs Leonard is close
Floyd loses to hearns . Hitman jab would dominate the fight
floyd loses to hagler. Not too many atg middleweights I would pick floyd to beat


floyd beats pac. Pac doesn't adjust
Floyd beats barrera. Barrera would fare the best out of the mexicans
Floyd beats marquez. Juan will miss all night
Floyd beats morales. Erik fights with his emotions too much to win against floyd.

floyd beats mosley. Mosley can't handle boxers. Mosley's only chance is a ko. He can't win a decision aginst floyd.
Floyd ****s Trinidad. Tito can't dodge a jab
Floyd vs oscar is close
Floyd vs winky is close

This is exactly how I see it. Although Floyd might lose to Winky as well. He definitely loses to Hearns and Hagler most likely but he beats the rest of those guys.

[HarvardBlue]

Floyd beats duran. Same Leonard gameplan.
Floyd vs Leonard is close
Floyd loses to hearns . Hitman jab would dominate the fight
floyd loses to hagler. Not too many atg middleweights I would pick floyd to beat


floyd beats pac. Pac doesn't adjust
Floyd beats barrera. Barrera would fare the best out of the mexicans
Floyd beats marquez. Juan will miss all night
Floyd beats morales. Erik fights with his emotions too much to win against floyd.

floyd beats mosley. Mosley can't handle boxers. Mosley's only chance is a ko. He can't win a decision aginst floyd.
Floyd ****s Trinidad. Tito can't dodge a jab
Floyd vs oscar is close
Floyd vs winky is close

Agree 100%.

[kiDynamite92]

Floyd beats duran. Same Leonard gameplan.
Floyd vs Leonard is close
Floyd loses to hearns . Hitman jab would dominate the fight
floyd loses to hagler. Not too many atg middleweights I would pick floyd to beat


floyd beats pac. Pac doesn't adjust
Floyd beats barrera. Barrera would fare the best out of the mexicans
Floyd beats marquez. Juan will miss all night
Floyd beats morales. Erik fights with his emotions too much to win against floyd.

floyd beats mosley. Mosley can't handle boxers. Mosley's only chance is a ko. He can't win a decision aginst floyd.
Floyd ****s Trinidad. Tito can't dodge a jab
Floyd vs oscar is close
Floyd vs winky is close

Agreed except for the Leonard part. SRL would be too big, too strong, too fast.

[HandsofIron]

Prime Duran, Hearns, Hagler & SRL?

Prime Oscar, Mosley, Trinidad & Winky Wright?

FW versions of Pac, Barrera, Morales & JMM from the 00's?

How would he fare against these groups of great fighters at there peak? Would this type of rivalry have brought out the best or worst in Floyd? He lacks those great rivalries so I was wondering how you think he would have done..

I know he fought Pac, Oscar, Mosley & JMM but they were all mid 30's to 40 or well above there best weights.

Floyd gets destroyed by the 5 Kings - Duran, SRL, Hearns, Hagler and Benitez (Why do people leave out Benitez? He's way better than Hagler).

Floyd beats Winky and all the other match-ups are pretty good toss-up fights. I'd say 50-50 for the rest.

[sbbigmike]

This is exactly how I see it. Although Floyd might lose to Winky as well. He definitely loses to Hearns and Hagler most likely but he beats the rest of those guys.

Winky ducked a 140 pound Floyd willing to jump up 2 divisions, we shouldn't be granting that chump any theoretical matches

[elgu]

Loses to duran- Duran at his best was an animal. People like to use the second leonard fight as an example but they should know that wasn't Duran at his best.

Loses to Leonard- Reach, speed, power, size, iq, and stamina advantages combined is a combination Floyd has never seen and I don't see him beating a guy that is just as good as him but bigger.

Loses to Hagler- Not a fair match because Floyd is not a middleweight. Hagler KO.

Loses to Hearns- Hearns by KO. Stylistic nightmare for Floyd.

Loses to prime Oscar- Past prime earned him a SD. Prime beats him by UD.

Beats Trinidad- Tito lacked boxing Iq, but Floyd needs to be careful.

Beats Mosley- Mosley is to one-dimensional.

Loses to Winky- Winky is too big, too active, and too good defensively to lose to Floyd.

Beats Barrera, Pac, Morales and JMM, - Just like Floyd is too small for leonard and hagler these guys are too small for him. Morales gives him the best fight.

[VatoMulatto]

Hearns, Hagler and SRL are the only ones I'm confident would beat him.

The only ones I'm confident Floyd would beat are Mosley, Oscar, Barrera, Pac, Morales and JMM.