Comments Thread For: Titles Changing Hands All Over: BoxingScene Ratings Update

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • HeroBando
    I love Mayweather
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Oct 2011
    • 17452
    • 236
    • 0
    • 24,430

    #11
    Originally posted by ShoulderRoll
    He listed Golovkin as having the WBC belt.

    Canelo is still lineal though.
    It points to a big flaw in the ratings system to have Canelo as #1 at Mw, right? It's total nonsense. So when your system is spitting out nonsense, you fix it. The Ring policy for stripping champs with no top 5 wins in 2 (?) years is a good start but clearly incomplete. Heres 2 more common sense criteria a lineal champ should meet

    1. It's ok to win it at a CW but you better defend at regulation weight
    2. You duck consensus #1 contender (eg by forfeiting your belt), you get stripped

    Makes a ton of sense, right? And guards against horrific lineal paper champs like Canelo. There's been some sketchy lineal champs before but this gotta be all time worst

    Comment

    Working...
    TOP