Accomplished Fighters @ Welterweight

[GrandpaBernard]

rank them in order of career accomplishments.

*exclude manny since he is retired

*exclude gift decisions

[GrandpaBernard]

Garcia [kicked Lucas and Amir azzes back when they were still glamour guys]

Timmeh [beat Marquez coming off his career win]

Amir [that Maidana win doe]

Brook [comfortably beat Porter]

Porter [beat Devon & Adrien]

Keith

[GrandpaBernard]

Looking to hear some other people's thoughts

[TheUptownKid]

Garcia [kicked Lucas and Amir azzes back when they were still glamour guys]

Timmeh [beat Marquez coming off his career win]

Amir [that Maidana win doe]

Brook [comfortably beat Porter]

Porter [beat Devon & Adrien]

Keith

Danny- Solid wins despite gifts

Tim- has a controversial win vs a legend but fought him closer than anyone not legendary status, beat marquez soundly

Thurman- I just think he's better and more sturdy than khan

Khan -I think that Maidana win was way weaker than it appears and he has a history of losing to lesser comp.


The rest are also rans, khan maybe should be an also ran too but I have Brook, Spence, Peterson and porter in this group maybe not in that order but yeah

[GrandpaBernard]

Danny- Solid wins despite gifts

Tim- has a controversial win vs a legend but fought him closer than anyone not legendary status, beat marquez soundly

Thurman- I just think he's better and more sturdy than khan

Khan -I think that Maidana win was way weaker than it appears and he has a history of losing to lesser comp.


The rest are also rans, khan maybe should be an also ran too but I have Brook, Spence, Peterson and porter in this group maybe not in that order but yeah

I like Keith and very happy that he'll be stepping up next month