Should There Be a Mayweather-Pacquiao Rematch?

[KLockard23]

It shouldn't happen again, a result in favour of each man proves nothing.

Another Floyd W leaves us right where we are now...The majority of fans will still be saying the same stuff. A Manny win would only prompt a third bout due to it being one W each, and a trilogy with these guys just isn't going to happen.

It is too late, and quite frankly the fight we all waited years and years for did not live up to any hype or expectation enough for a call of rematch to be made. The only reason some people want it again is due to controversy before and after the fight, not the actual fight itself. It wasn't a great fight, it wasn't as bad as it is made out to be, but it should by no means be classed better than a 'good' fight that 80/90% of people aren't really up for seeing again.

If it did happen again, don't get me wrong, it will have my interest...But as of right now, it is too late for this talk and in all honesty the actual fight did not warrant a rematch, the murky water before and after it did, and messy back and forth controversy isn't what the real fans want to look foreward too, lets be honest.

Why wouldn't a trilogy be feasible? These guys are pushing 40, not 50. And a Manny win wouldn't just be tying Floyd's victory, it would make him the first and only person to ever defeat Mayweather, which would be huge in itself.

[SthPaw]

Why wouldn't a trilogy be feasible? These guys are pushing 40, not 50. And a Manny win wouldn't just be tying Floyd's victory, it would make him the first and only person to ever defeat Mayweather, which would be huge in itself.

I just can't see them ever getting a trilogy done man...It isn't impossible in this game, but I just really can't see it.

But I agree a Manny W would be huge because of it being over Floyd, that is a fair point, but in the bigger picture I feel as though most fans would be quick to jump on the "Ahh they are tied, they just need to go again" and it would seem tiresome as hell seeing as it would be all you would hear for a long long time. People still argue about their actual fight and that was a year ago. BUT, that being said, as the years go by and it became 'history' THEN it would be seen as a massive deal, I agree.

I just don't see the rematch but like I said, in this game, who knows.

[Larry the boss]

Why can't ya'll move on?? both are retired...Floyd is 39 Manny is 37....1st fight showed you there will be no action...Let it go

[SthPaw]

Yes, they are past their prime to give a concrete argument who is the best. That's why to most. It's just a farewell fight for the ages. Still the 2 best fighters in the same division duking it out is a rarity in itself and that my friend is enough to make a boxing aficionado to watch.

Since Pac didn't get a fair shake with all the murkiness on that fight. A rematch is a must watch since Pac really did tear his rotator cuff and a healthy Pac would have been a different fight altogether. An exhibition fight with a green light for carnage should be their farewell fight for them. After all, they are the 2 best boxers in the game it is only fitting to close the curtain together. I have a feeling if no bayless on that fight, and Floyd is not allowed to clinch excessively by a ref we got an exciting barn burner fight in our hands.

Still Nothing will be concluded, but at least we get to watch the best of the sport has to offer one last time.

Yeah man, that is what I meant by it would have my attention if it did happen, I am not gonna lie. I am a fan of this sport and of both guys, of course I would get into it if they where to go again. I just mean in terms of how unlikely it is for it to happen and the increased unlikeliness for a rubber match should Manny win a rematch...I just don't see it. It is too messy, too much to clear up etc and too much BS with fanbases to ever leave us all with a clear answer.

Say they rematch and Manny scores a W, aside from adding more history to his legend in eventually beating Floyd, what does it do for the casuals and biased fanbases of both guys? It would just make them cry for a third bout, and that just seems all the more unlikely too me, so in terms of the rivalry we are still left with controversy and little answers as to who is 'the man'.

As I said in another post, who knows...Nobody can say for sure what will happen in this sport, but these too rematching is just something I personally do not see.

[Larry the boss]

I think id rather see the extreme T@rds and fl0mos who refuse to move on locked in a cage and fight till the death

[Spoon23]

Yeah man, that is what I meant by it would have my attention if it did happen, I am not gonna lie. I am a fan of this sport and of both guys, of course I would get into it if they where to go again. I just mean in terms of how unlikely it is for it to happen and the increased unlikeliness for a rubber match should Manny win a rematch...I just don't see it. It is too messy, too much to clear up etc and too much BS with fanbases to ever leave us all with a clear answer.

Say they rematch and Manny scores a W, aside from adding more history to his legend in eventually beating Floyd, what does it do for the casuals and biased fanbases of both guys? It would just make them cry for a third bout, and that just seems all the more unlikely too me, so in terms of the rivalry we are still left with controversy and little answers as to who is 'the man'.

As I said in another post, who knows...Nobody can say for sure what will happen in this sport, but these too rematching is just something I personally do not see.

Win, lose or draw to either man if ever their will be a rematch will be the last fight of their career.

The plots:

Will Floyd make it 50-0 against his rival?

Will Pac healthy shoulder make a difference?

It is only to feature the last fight of these 2 boxers as they end it properly together as the curtains go down for the last time of their stellar career. Who's better to end it with than with each other.

This is for the fans of the sport. A farewell fight for both combatants and logic tells us that it will be better this time around. A 2 handed healthy Pac vs a clean Floyd with vada testing. I know it's a long shot. But, I'm just getting it out there. Plus the fact both boxers based on their history do great on their rematches.

Yes, Nothing will be conclusive since they are not in their prime, but that said, even if they are not in their prime anymore we will still be able to appreciate the 2 best boxers of this era duke it out one last time, since they are still in the top p4p to most even to this day.

It only becomes irrelevant if this 2 past their prime boxers are out of the p4p standings, that can be said as a nonsense fight, but the thing is they are still the best the sport has to offer, I say that's good reason enough to warrant a fight. To see the 2 go at it one last time. The one who wins will go out on a high note, the one who loses will carry that forever. There is still sense for this 2 to fight. Evident to this poll.

Will I want to see Michael Jordan and Kobe Bryant in the same court for a basketball exhibition past their prime? Hell yes I will still watch that.

Will I want to see Pac and Floyd in the same ring although past their prime, but still top p4p nonetheless duke it out? He'll yes! Off course, if you really are a boxing aficionado you will take it.

Anyway, just my 2 cents. Cheers!

[Zaroku]

Win, lose or draw to either man if ever their will be a rematch will be the last fight of their career.

The plots:

Will Floyd make it 50-0 against his rival?

Will Pac healthy shoulder make a difference?

It is only to feature the last fight of these 2 boxers as they end it properly together as the curtains go down for the last time of their stellar career. Who's better to end it with than with each other.

This is for the fans of the sport. A farewell fight for both combatants and logic tells us that it will be better this time around. A 2 handed healthy Pac vs a clean Floyd with vada testing. I know it's a long shot. But, I'm just getting it out there.

Nothing will be conclusive since they are not in their prime, but that said, even if they are not in their prime anymore we will still be able to appreciate the 2 best boxers of this era duke it out one last time, since they are still in the top p4p to most even to this day.

It only becomes irrelevant if this 2 past their prime boxers are out of the p4p standings, that can be said as a nonsense fight, but the thing is they are still the best the sport has to offer, I say that's good reason enough to warrant a fight. To see the 2 go at it one last time. The one who wins still will go out on a high note, the one who loses will carry that forever. There is still sense for this 2 to fight. Evident to this poll.

Anyway, just my 2 cents. Cheers!

Spoon, what happened to you buddy. Your temp ban seems to have grounded you(temporarily) in reality. I wanted you back. Glad to have you back, but you are less ****** now, but where is the old spoon??

You don't acknowledge your brother Zaroku who wanted you back. Your brother who never ran to the mods, in spite of your blatant ******ity. I got your t@rded back.

Welcome back!!

[Spoon23]

Win, lose or draw to either man if ever their will be a rematch will be the last fight of their career.

The plots:

Will Floyd make it 50-0 against his rival?

Will Pac healthy shoulder make a difference?

It is only to feature the last fight of these 2 boxers as they end it properly together as the curtains go down for the last time of their stellar career. Who's better to end it with than with each other.

This is for the fans of the sport. A farewell fight for both combatants and logic tells us that it will be better this time around. A 2 handed healthy Pac vs a clean Floyd with vada testing. I know it's a long shot. But, I'm just getting it out there. Plus the fact both boxers based on their history do great on their rematches.

Yes, Nothing will be conclusive since they are not in their prime, but that said, even if they are not in their prime anymore we will still be able to appreciate the 2 best boxers of this era duke it out one last time, since they are still in the top p4p to most even to this day.

It only becomes irrelevant if this 2 past their prime boxers are out of the p4p standings, that can be said as a nonsense fight, but the thing is they are still the best the sport has to offer, I say that's good reason enough to warrant a fight. To see the 2 go at it one last time. The one who wins will go out on a high note, the one who loses will carry that forever. There is still sense for this 2 to fight. Evident to this poll.

Will I want to see Michael Jordan and Kobe Bryant in the same court for a basketball exhibition past their prime? Hell yes I will still watch that.

Will I want to see Pac and Floyd in the same ring although past their prime, but still top p4p nonetheless duke it out? He'll yes! Off course, if you really are a boxing aficionado you will take it.

Anyway, just my 2 cents. Cheers!

Spoon, what happened to you buddy. Your temp ban seems to have grounded you(temporarily) in reality. I wanted you back. Glad to have you back, but you are less ****** now, but where is the old spoon??

You don't acknowledge your brother Zaroku who wanted you back. Your brother who never ran to the mods, in spite of your blatant ******ity. I got your t@rded back.

Welcome back!!

What I think is really dumb is the fact you can say dumb freely without any logic to back up what I just wrote. That my friend is below zero dumb. Your flip flopping mind shows your lack of control to your mental state my friend. I think you should understand the term dumb before using it freely. Mirror is your friend buddy. I'd rather not accept your welcome, coz that is the dumbest way to welcome someone.

Take it easy Sugarkainhook. May your bipolar mind find center and be one again.

[Rath]

genius floyd fans don't want a rematch they were lucky enough as it was to get away with the two fluids (correction fluid and the IV fluid scandal) to get a win.

[Zaroku]

What I think is really dumb is the fact you can say dumb freely without any logic to back up what I just wrote. That my friend is below zero dumb. Your flip flopping mind shows your lack of control to your mental state my friend. I think you should understand the term dumb before using it freely. Mirror is your friend buddy. I'd rather not accept your welcome, coz that is the dumbest way to welcome someone.

Take it easy Sugarkainhook. May your bipolar mind find center and be one again.

Ouch! I asked the mods when are you gonna come back. We all know about your fragile state of mind. Must have hurt you badly to be banned.

I am glad you are back, I missed your idiotic threads. Your public poll isn't going well, but it is accurate. Objectivity and accuracy are what you lack. Many see you as a t@rd, I prefer hard core fan.

Welcome back buddy!!