Was Pacquiao a Joe Frasier

[fanofslug]

Not in fighting style, but in the sense that he would have dominated the HW division if it wasn't for Ali. Would Pacquiao have reigned supreme if there was no Mayweather?

[GrandpaBernard]

Not in fighting style, but in the sense that he would have dominated the HW division if it wasn't for Ali. Would Pacquiao have reigned supreme if there was no Mayweather?

He also got destroyed by someone else like Frazier. Marquez = Foreman

[SilverMiles]

Pacquiao did dominate the WW from 2009 to 2012. Floyd did regain control of the division until about maybe 2013, but even then it took him 2 more years to step up.

And Ali hardly dominated Heavyweight after his return to the sport. He lost to Frazier and never could get a clean victory over Norton, many people believe Norton won the series.

Frazier and Manny have little in common, Manny is the man of his era across all weight classes while Frazier was just a great heavyweight.

[daggum]

there was no mayweather for almost his entire career and he dominated ww a lot more than floyd. floyd's ww resume was utter trash until pac which easily could have gone to the other way

[GrandpaBernard]

Mind changed.

Frazier beat his nemesis one time. manny couldn't do it.

[fanofslug]

Pacquiao did dominate the WW from 2009 to 2012. Floyd did regain control of the division until about maybe 2013, but even then it took him 2 more years to step up.

And Ali hardly dominated Heavyweight after his return to the sport. He lost to Frazier and never could get a clean victory over Norton, many people believe Norton won the series.

Frazier and Manny have little in common, Manny is the man of his era across all weight classes while Frazier was just a great heavyweight.

After Ali retired Foreman there was a possibility of Frasier dominating the HW if it wasn't for Ali-Frasier 3? Similarly, if there was no Mayweather around 2010 Manny would have been dominant. 2009-2012 WW was more of a coming out party for Manny, he was just settling in. Thanks.

[SilverMiles]

After Ali retired Foreman there was a possibility of Frasier dominating the HW if it wasn't for Ali-Frasier 3? Similarly, if there was no Mayweather around 2010 Manny would have been dominant. 2009-2012 WW was more of a coming out party for Manny, he was just settling in. Thanks.

He literally beat every top WW doing that time. The era Manny dominated was the WW era Cotto, Clottey, Mosley, and Margarito.

The one Mayweather went on to dominate was one going through a transition period. It's unfortunate Mayweather didn't fight the best of his WW era but rather the young less proven guys on the come up who all went on to do nothing afterwards.

You can say the two ruled the division as 1A and 1B but Manny was p4p number 1 from 2008 to 2012, he remained #1 even after "losing" to Bradley. Thanks for the reply.

[Larry the boss]

there was no mayweather for almost his entire career and he dominated ww a lot more than floyd. floyd's ww resume was utter trash until pac which easily could have gone to the other way

Makes 0 damn sense..Floyd won every single title at ww and was a 2 time lineal champion there...Manny Beat 2 ww champions in Cotto and Bradley..thats it

[Larry the boss]

He literally beat every top WW doing that time. The era Manny dominated was the WW era Cotto, Clottey, Mosley, and Margarito.

The one Mayweather went on to dominate was one going through a transition period. It's unfortunate Mayweather didn't fight the best of his WW era but rather the young less proven guys on the come up who all went on to do nothing afterwards.

You can say the two ruled the division as 1A and 1B but Manny was p4p number 1 from 2008 to 2012, he remained #1 even after "losing" to Bradley. Thanks for the reply.

lol..Floyd beat more top ww's then Manny by a large margin

You listed Mosley who was coming off of a loss and a draw??
Clottey coming off of a loss
Margarito coming off of a ko and a suspension at 150?? makes no sense what you just posted..floyd beat

Baldo-lineal champ,wbc champ
Mosely-wba champ
Ortiz-wbc champ
Maidana-wba champ
Manny-wbo champ
Judah-ibf champ

how can you even compare the 2?

[SilverMiles]

lol..Floyd beat more top ww's then Manny by a large margin

You listed Mosley who was coming off of a loss and a draw??
Clottey coming off of a loss
Margarito coming off of a ko and a suspension at 150?? makes no sense what you just posted..floyd beat

Baldo-lineal champ,wbc champ
Mosely-wba champ
Ortiz-wbc champ
Maidana-wba champ
Manny-wbo champ
Judah-ibf champ

how can you even compare the 2?

Clottey coming off a loss is still better than Ortiz and Guerreroe.

Fuq a Baldomir, it's Judah fault he won a title. Clottey also beat Judah's ass. He was also beating Baldomir's ass before that bull**** DQ.