Manny Pacquaio vs Juan Manuel Marquez 3 Appreciation thread: Did JMM get robbed?

[daggum]

kinda was the point of the thread to compare scorecards....not bicker

I cant see manny winning this fight, each round I gave to each fighter is explained


Sorry man, Im not one of those posters who rides with one fighter or the other, I just score the fights. I dont gain anything or add to the forum being biased

I respect your opinion

well usually if you score a fight one way its very hard to score it a different way upon second viewing so having 2 scorecards is kinda pointless. you yourself said there were 5 even rounds so someone else might think differently then you and give even rouns to pac and thats why it's not a clear win for either guy. definition of a close fight. floyd-pac was much more decisive in pac's favor than this fight. he was the one landing the much cleaner punches in the close rounds in that fight while floyd's were grazing/not clean. pac marquez was more even with both guys landing cleanly.

[therealpugilist]

well usually if you score a fight one way its very hard to score it a different way upon second viewing so having 2 scorecards is kinda pointless. you yourself said there were 5 even rounds so someone else might think differently then you and give even rouns to pac and thats why it's not a clear win for either guy. definition of a close fight. floyd-pac was much more decisive in pac's favor than this fight. he was the one landing the much cleaner punches in the close rounds in that fight while floyd's were grazing/not clean. pac marquez was more even with both guys landing cleanly.

blah blah blah...im not reading all of that...anybody with a brain knows their were rounds that depended on the viewer how they were scored


Marquez won in my opinion...case closed...we can agree to disagree....Floyd clearly beat Manny, Marquez did, as did Morales


it just opinion, no need to get all emo about scorecards


fights are scored round by round and I gave my reasoning for who got the rounds...i only scored two rounds even....even when I didnt Marquez won

[FrankieClutch]

Good stuff Pugilist. You should do Canelo-Trout or Lara next.

[therealpugilist]

Good stuff Pugilist. You should do Canelo-Trout or Lara next.

Thats a good shout...looking for fights that have kinda marinated in our heads...that Lara fight may be next, I watched it, but didnt score it....looked like a draw but I'll have to sit down and score it one day

[FrankieClutch]

Thats a good shout...looking for fights that have kinda marinated in our heads...that Lara fight may be next, I watched it, but didnt score it....looked like a draw but I'll have to sit down and score it one day

Well sh.t, do Martinez vs Williams 1 then! That's had enough time to marinate and that was razor thin

[therealpugilist]

Well sh.t, do Martinez vs Williams 1 then! That's had enough time to marinate and that was razor thin

great idea...and it was a fight of the year calibre fight...definitely will be doing that fight and havent watched it since it was live on HBO

[fanofslug]

Oh yeah, massively robbed.

Avatar of Khan. Red bomb sent. You're welcome.

[Twako]

That was the first one I did genius and all the idiots claiming JLC was robbed didnt even bother to score the fight and just trolled


fight was no robbery couldve gone either way, if you think it was a robbery you need to learn how to score fights

you're more of an idiot if you think pac-jmm3 is more of a robbery than floyd-castillo 1

[therealpugilist]

you're more of an idiot if you think pac-jmm3 is more of a robbery than floyd-castillo 1

it was


watched both fights live and scored them numerous times.....ive scored the fight in castillos favor and floyds...its a toss..I never scored pAC-jmm 3 in Manny's favor....scored it a draw giving manny the close rounds....we can agree to disagree...i dont take anyone serious who comments on fights but dont have any analysis.....hollatcha later

[b00g13man]

Gotta say I'm loving these threads. It'd be nice if some losers didn't try to ruin em.