Is Sergio Martinez hall of fame worthy?

[Larry the boss]

Vote and discuss

[therealpugilist]

I voted no...but if I compared him to the resume Gatti, Mcguigan and Manicini have an they got in, Maravilla should be first ballot lol

[BrometheusBob.]

Would lean towards no

[DreamerUSA]

Would lean towards no

Probably not but, he likely will though at some point.

[SilverMiles]

I say yes, guy was one of best MW of this era, short reign on top compared to guys like Monzon and Hagler but he got some defenses in there.

[Tails]

I personally don't think so (I think it should truly be reserved for those that were simply outstanding during their prime years like a legend) but I do expect him to eventually be put in later on after he is initially eligible similar to Naseem Hamed.

[RA-Box]

Yes, for the Hall of Fame as it is.

No, for the Hall of Fame as it should be.

[therealpugilist]

Yes, for the Hall of Fame as it is.

No, for the Hall of Fame as it should be.

^^^^^nuff said

[paulf]

I voted no...but if I compared him to the resume Gatti, Mcguigan and Manicini have an they got in, Maravilla should be first ballot lol

Exactly this.

[Motofan]

Yes, for the Hall of Fame as it is.

No, for the Hall of Fame as it should be.

Agreed. Sergio was one of my favorite fighters, but when I think of HOF I think it should only be the absolute best of the best.