is it safe to say jacobs is the 2nd best mw?

[danceswithfire]

atm after GGG

[.!WAR MIKEY!.]

sure.....................

[danceswithfire]

sure.....................

canelo is the catchweight king

[danceswithfire]

is it also safe to say Jacobs win over quilin >>>>>>any GGG win

[buge]

is it also safe to say Jacobs win over quilin >>>>>>any GGG win

No, Andy Lee is about even with Quillen (per their draw), and Lemieux has about the same career path / record / standing as Andy Lee.

So I think the Quillen win is about even with a Lemieux win. GGG has many more top10 wins than just that one though.

[.!WAR MIKEY!.]

canelo is the catchweight king

sure.....................

[fragilety]

where is all this coming from? because a quick ko? if anything that result answard very little, if they fought again I doubt it would happen like that and who knows what result we would get.. before Cotto was the lineal champ and 2nd/3rd best with people putting David Limenux in the same position followed by Andy Lee and Danny Jacobs/Peter Quillin depending on the person, no one ever considered Jacobs as much I know I watch these forums and the Amnesia most people tend to suffer from when it comes to remembering **** on here

[danceswithfire]

No, Andy Lee is about even with Quillen (per their draw), and Lemieux has about the same career path / record / standing as Andy Lee.

So I think the Quillen win is about even with a Lemieux win. GGG has many more top10 wins than just that one though.

so GGG's advantage over Jacobs is only over quantity not quality, fair assessment I guess

[SilverMiles]

No. It's GGG than Canelo. Toss up between Lemule and Jacobs.

[The Problem Child]

I like the guy, I would hate to see Gennady destroy him. It's not a beating I would enjoy. I hope he loses the belt to someone else or something. He is a guy I want to see succeed and be well.