Who has the better resume..Khan or GGG

[-Kev-]

How much weight should we put on Khan's losses?

Garcia destroyed him in 4
Pretty close fight with Peterson, decision loss
Destroyed by Prescott in 1

On top of that, we have:

An either-way fight with Algieri
An extremely close fight with Diaz

Of course, we have decent wins over Maidana and Judah. On top of that we have wins over an older Barrera, Paulie and Kotelnik. I think the wins over Maidana and Judah alone are better than anything Golovkin has done, but it entirely depends on how much weight you want to put on his losses, two of which were pretty devastating. Golovkin on the otherhand has steamrolled through everyone he has faced.

Resume-wise? Khan has better wins, but also devastating losses to fighters who aren't that great

In terms of whos the better fighter, you'd have to put the money on Golovkin. He just needs to extend his resume to reflect his ability more

Khan struggled badly with Algieri and Peterson, but I had him winning both fights. The Algieri fight was pretty frustrating because I was rooting for Algieri to win but he let that fight go himself. I can't really see how it could go either way, it was a clear, struggling loss. I was rooting for Peterson to beat him as well, but had Khan winning by 1 point.

[Jedi Vader]

Just his wins over Maidana and Alexander completely defecates anything on Lickle G's resume.

[ИATAS]

Such an edgy thread Larry!!

[Jc8804]

Khan slightly.

To GGGs credit .he has never been iced
Like khan

[nivek535]

so to summarize the discussion thus far, the strongest points are as follows:

-khan has the better names and wins on paper.
-khan's performance against them were not grade A performances.
-ggg's resume is full of contenders.
-however, ggg took these contenders out not only by boxing them, but knocking em all out.


my opinion is:
**** resumes, who cares??
GGG is the better guy p4p in my book.

[BennyST]

You simply cannot, with any sense of honesty and self integrity, say GGG. What he does have going for him over Khan is that the guys he has beaten, he has demolished, whereas Khan has struggled with some guys of that lower level or even lost in the case of Prescott because of his ****ty chin and flawed technique.

However, Khan is way beyond GGG in terms of resume.

[Mr. Philadel]

Khan's TKO loss to Danny Garcia is better than any win on GGG's resume

Lil G is in bad place with MOST not ALL but MOST knowledgeable boxing fans....there's a loud vocal group of kids who REALLY believe dude is a beast...then there's those who see through all the hype

[BlackSoul]

exactly.
ggg didnt just win against all the top contenders.. he stopped them, always in pretty devastating fashion too. damn.

key word CONTENDERS

[STAX ON DECK]

u have to be ******ed as hell to vote for ggg

[Real King Kong]

You mean who has the more recognizable names on their resume. Until the fighters on ggg's resume fight the fighters on khan's resume in some alternate universe where they're the same size we'll never know. People here talk about resume too much. It's not like we're talking about their atg status here...their careers aren't even over yet. As long as they are both looking to fight the best available opposition, then who cares. It's just become a way for fan boys of one fighter to trash another.