If Pac and PBF both spent their primes in the Fab Four Era...

[LoadedWraps]

Who retires with the better resume?

Discuss.

[Larry the boss]

Both would be to damn small for ww so i really do not get the question..both would max out at 140

[LoadedWraps]

Both would be to damn small for ww so i really do not get the question..both would max out at 140

Both were still in their prime when they hit ww though. Floyd fould Oscar past it. Pac fought Margarito at ww.

[DeadLikeMe]

Floyd would still easily beat Manny so he'd be 1-4...maybe 2-3. Manny loses to all 5 so he'd be 0-5. Giving Floyd the slight edge.

[Larry the boss]

Both were still in their prime when they hit ww though. Floyd fould Oscar past it. Pac fought Margarito at ww.

Not the same man....Hearn ended up at light heavy..Leonard went up to 168 Hagler was a middleweight..Duran is the only reasonable opponent and i think both have a chance at beating him...he was the weak link out of the 4

[Larry the boss]

Not really fair as Leonard,Hearns both began at 147 and Hagler was a middleweight

[Larry the boss]

Manny and Mayweather would be fighting Aaron Pryor and arguello etc

[nivek535]

Both would be to damn small for ww so i really do not get the question..both would max out at 140

agreed,
140 is quite late already.....
i dont see much chance for pac/may against leonard/hearns and definitely not hagler (160, duh)...
maybe duran. but he did start at 130 unlike may/pac who started in much lighter weight classes

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Floyd stays at 135-140, manny at 126-130...


Neither jumps up with the big boys like benitez, leonard, hearns

[Raonic]

It really depends. If Floyd fought the same amount of fights (49 fights), I don't think he'd get as much praise as he does now.