list fighters who have good/solid resumes,but were won under weak circumstances,,

[STAX ON DECK]

Ponce, paulie



Love doesn't have a great resume, but most of his marquee wins came by a debatable decision ie rosado

fair enough,,

although it can be debated that paulie was not at any disadvanatge whatsoever,while it was in fact,broner,who moved up 2 entire weight classes to fight him at his natural weight class,,and all paulie did was jab all night,no one felt it was a robbery

ill give u ponce tho

[Sugar Adam Ali]

fair enough,,

although it can be debated that paulie was not at any disadvanatge whatsoever,while it was in fact,broner,who moved up 2 entire weight classes to fight him at his natural weight class,,and all paulie did was jab all night,no one felt it was a robbery

ill give u ponce tho

I thought Broner beat paulie cleanly, but I have seen a lot of posters claim paulie won and it was a very competitive fight for the most part.. I don't agree but a lot of posters think it was a controversial win

[b00g13man]

I thought Broner beat paulie cleanly, but I have seen a lot of posters claim paulie won and it was a very competitive fight for the most part.. I don't agree but a lot of posters think it was a controversial win

I scored it 7-5 for Paulie, but it could've easily swung the other way. It's not a decision I'd ever cry about, but struggling with Paulie tells you all you need to know about a fighter.

[Earl-Hickey]

Miguel Cotto

Mosley-robbery
Clottey-Robbery
Marg 2 - one eye
Martine - no knees
Foreman - one leg

[soul_survivor]

Saw the thread title, and immediately thought of Danny. The Khan and Lucas wins are legit, but it's been kinda "meh" from him since.

yeah but apart from that lw it's not like he has been fighting bums, the guy has faced Peterson, Judah and so on. Peterson is still very relevant, the Matthysse fight wasn't exactly a decade ago and Judah was still a top 10 lww. It's the very definition of a good resume. If people are trying to say it's a great resume, then sure but a good resume has such wins and close wins etc. I think it's a weak pick.

Cotto's middleweight run is what should be mentioned, an injured Martinez and a shot, scared and drained Geale up for it only for the money.

We can add Broner, whose best win is probably PDL some 3 or 4 years ago and even that was a very, very close fight. Malignaggi, a guy nearing the very end of his career (had a bit of an Indian summer) is the second best win and he almost got outworked lol

[STAX ON DECK]

bump.......