Top 10 (2000-2015)

[Doctor_Tenma]

hopkins win lol come on. that was a clear robbery. hopkins landed all the clean punches and calzaghe just kept walking into them. very silly to try and use a robbery as proof that calzaghe's great. ottke had many robberies as well so is he as great? kessler was a good win but that's it. a good win. ottke beat glen johnson who is actually more accomplished than kessler being linear champ at 175 with wins over tarver and roy. erdei also was the linear champ at 175, something kessler never was. i'm really not seeing much difference between these guys. the hopkins win is really the only thing that stands out and yea that was not a win. if calzaghe won that fight then porter beat brook.

Lately you've been bitching about fighters being dirty, what was Hopkins doing against Calzaghe then? Where do you even stand anymore?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I actually retract Trinidad from my list and replaced him with winky. Tito was much more of a 90s fighter, which is why I didn't include Roy, de la hoya, mosley or Lennox as well. I completely forgot about winky tho

I think klitchko, calzaghe and cotto are all interchangeable imo and I wouldn't have too much of a problem with either of them ranked ahead of the other.

What's a fair and logical assessment.. Totally agree

[Sugar Adam Ali]

1 floyd
2 manny
3 hopkins
4 calzaghe
5 marquez
6 barrera
7 Wlad
8 winky
9 morales
10 Cotto


Honorable mention: donaire, Martinez,

Scratch that, forgot about Ward
1 floyd
2 manny
3 hopkins
4 Ward
5 calzaghe
6 marquez
7 barrera
8 wlad
9 winky
10 morales

[Sosay]

1 floyd
2 manny
3 hopkins
4 Wlad
5 marquez
6 barrera
7 Winky
8 Calzaghe
9 morales
10 Cotto

[therealpugilist]

if calzaghe's on the list where is sven ottke? or how about zsolt erdei? artur grigorian?

Oh yea... the guys who hi-jacked alphabet belts and fought manadatories with out fighting the best in their divisions.....Calzaghe started to towards the end of his career....his fights with Jones and Hopkins was safe fights he chose to took....He wasn't going anywhere near them before they were old azz men.

[gamesworn]

1. Pacquiao
2. Mayweather
3. Hopkins
4. Marquez
5. Barrera
6. Morales
7. Calzhage
8. Wlad
9. Winky
10. Cotto/Ward/Donaire

[SilverMiles]

1. Pacquiao
2. Marquez
3. Mayweather
4. Morales
5. Barrera
6. Calzaghe
7. Hopkins
8. Donaire
9. Cotto
10.Bradley