The P4P Top 10 Fighters Are All Non-Americans

[boliodogs]

Pound for pound is just personal opinion and can't be proven one way or the other. It's based on how good you think a fighter is for his size. It's based on how good you think the fighter is right now and his potential and not on his accomplishments. No two people will ever agree on a top ten list and no list is more correct or wrong than any other list. There is nothing special about your list and it's no more right or wrong than anybody else's list. Lots of people have Ward on their top 10 pfp list and some have him number 1. Personally I would not have Cotto on my list and Khan wouldn't be on a top 100 list of mine. That doesn't make either you or I correct. We both have a right to our opinions and when it comes to pound for pound lists everybody's list is perfect. Perfect for them anyway.

[New England]

divorce hit this one hard. $20 says he's been on the bottle since the morning, and is in no condition to take back custody of his children.


it's a cruel, cruel world.

[Weltschmerz]

Pound for pound is just personal opinion and can't be proven one way or the other. It's based on how good you think a fighter is for his size. It's based on how good you think the fighter is right now and his potential and not on his accomplishments. No two people will ever agree on a top ten list and no list is more correct or wrong than any other list. There is nothing special about your list and it's no more right or wrong than anybody else's list. Lots of people have Ward on their top 10 pfp list and some have him number 1. Personally I would not have Cotto on my list and Khan wouldn't be on a top 100 list of mine. That doesn't make either you or I correct. We both have a right to our opinions and when it comes to pound for pound lists everybody's list is perfect. Perfect for them anyway.

How can you have an inactive fighter number 1 on your list?

[Weltschmerz]

divorce hit this one hard. $20 says he's been on the bottle since the morning, and is in no condition to take back custody of his children.


it's a cruel, cruel world.

No trolling please, this is a serious boxing discussion.

Also, Kovalev crushes Ward.

[Barcham]

Cotto does not belong on the list. No fighter who only fights at a catchweight deserves to be on a P4P list.

[Weltschmerz]

Cotto does not belong on the list. No fighter who only fights at a catchweight deserves to be on a P4P list.

Hahaha...

Floyd Mayweather liked catchweights a lot.

[boliodogs]

I was wondering how you could have Khan on your list with his losses to Peterson and Prescott and his most recent KO loss to Garcia. Garcia is undefeated with a KO win over Khan and yet he is not on your list. Does Khan's wins over Diaz, Alexander, Algieri and Collazo actually cancel out his KO loss to Garcia and raise him above his KO conqueror? Not to me. To me undefeated American Garcia is well above Khan in any pound for pound list. If Khan defeated Garcia in a rematch then and only then should he rate above Garcia pfp.

[boliodogs]

How can you have an inactive fighter number 1 on your list?

You should read my post more carefully. I said many people have Ward on their pound for pound list and some have him number one. I never said I had Ward on my pound for pound list did I now? I don't have Ward on my pound for pound list at all because he has done nothing special since KOing Dawson years ago. You assumed I said Ward was number one but if you read what I said slowly and carefully it should be clear I never said that.

[Pigeons]

Hahaha...

Floyd Mayweather liked catchweights a lot.

The #5 fighter on your list has demanded and received a catchweight in 4 of his last 11 fights.

[Jsmooth9876]

Any list that has Khan and Brook on it over Garcia and Bradley is a Fkin joke. And Now that Ward is active again he needs to be on it as well. Maybe not at 2 behind Wlad but somewhere in the top 10