Who's the best P4P

[Shanus]

Case can be made for other guys in people's lists. If we were to try and explain why someone was ranked how high they are....we'd end up in an off topic discussion and nothing would get done. For the sake of rankings....Manny Pacquiao, Ronald Wright, and Floyd Mayweather Jr are the top 3 fighters in the sport because of their opposition faced and beaten etc.

I'd personally rank Castillo higher and maybe at the two spot but It's really hard considering he has 5 losses from cuts on his record and that has to count for something. He's beaten the best level of opposition out of everyone IMO.

You were spot on with the top 3, the reason I don't have Castillo in my top 5 is because of the earlier losses in his career as you mentioned, but those who are from the range of 4-8 on my list are there because of their recent accomplishments, no doubt Castillo will be replacing one of the top 5 names on my list once he beats Chico in their rubber match.

[SonnyG8R]

It's pretty close between Winky and mayweather. Mayweather is probably no. 1 right now but if Winky beats Taylor he wll take over the top spot.

[blockhead]

taylor tyrd and milk dud head do not belong on any p4p poll.

[blockhead]

taylor tyrd and milk dud head do not belong on any p4p poll.

nor does chico.

[strongisland24]

if taylor beats wright which he most likely will, he should be in the top 3 easy.

[Shanus]

if taylor beats wright which he most likely will, he should be in the top 3 easy.

IF Taylor beats Wright, He will replace Ronald on my list.

[7001]

WHERE IS JOE CALZAGHE ON YOUR POLL????

WJAY HAPPENED TO RICKY HATTON?????

Sorry I had room for 10. I personally don't think either one of them belongs in a top 10 list of P4P. Definately in my top 10 for fighters I like to watch. But so is Gatti. I was talking on skill P4P. Notice I didn't put Zab in there either.

[restless_438]

I've kind of made a decision to have a tie in my #1 spot between Mayweather and Wright, the only way one or the other would hold the title solely being if one of them does something overly impressive, it really depends, but as of right now, i have it a tie between Pretty Boy and Winky, but my vote goes to Wright.

[7001]

I've kind of made a decision to have a tie in my #1 spot between Mayweather and Wright, the only way one or the other would hold the title solely being if one of them does something overly impressive, it really depends, but as of right now, i have it a tie between Pretty Boy and Winky, but my vote goes to Wright.

Winky is a solid fighter. But all in all PBF gets mine. I just like his style and speed. Great Boxer. Both of them.

[Mr. Ryan]

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Winky Wright
4. Marco Antonio Barrera
5. Rafael Marquez