What prime bonafide ATG did these fighters defeat

[therealpugilist]

Julio Cesar Chavez
Alexis Arguello
Rocky Marciano
Larry Holmes
Wilfredo Gomez
Gene Fullmer
Joe Calzaghe



People on this site just don't understand how rare it is to see a true ATG take an L against another ATG.....their are only a few each generation so I firmly believe you overall body of work makes you great, not just one big win or having one guys number.....For example Aaron Pryor did beat Alexis Arguello but Arguello never defeated a prime ATG.....DOESNT CHANGE THE FACT ARGUELLO IS STILL AN ATG

[therealpugilist]

Some guys on this forum stick to agendas I call a spade a spade


Not every ATG beat a prime AT

Fighters can't pick eras they fight in


Some are weaker or stronger than others

[daggum]

Some guys on this forum stick to agendas I call a spade a spade


Not every ATG beat a prime AT

Fighters can't pick eras they fight in


Some are weaker or stronger than others

but they can pick when to fight fighters and for example floyd waited 5 years to fight cotto and pac for no reason other than fear and he waited for them to slow down and become tame. how lame.

[Jsmooth9876]

Hey, it's the daily I Blow Floyd Mayweather thread from the OP.

[Johnwoo8686]

but they can pick when to fight fighters and for example floyd waited 5 years to fight cotto and pac for no reason other than fear and he waited for them to slow down and become tame. how lame.

You didn't answer his question and you're exactly the problem he's talking about.

[JrX]

You didn't answer his question and you're exactly the problem he's talking about.

He aint lying, mayweather could have truly been a top 5 atg. He chose to play it safe

[-PBP-]

Logic is flawed because most have Floyd ranked above those guys. The prime ATG issue comes up when you compare him with the absolute best of the best.

Your Duran, Robinson, Leonard's and Alis

[Larry the boss]

but they can pick when to fight fighters and for example floyd waited 5 years to fight cotto and pac for no reason other than fear and he waited for them to slow down and become tame. how lame.

Bull****..Manny is the one who turned the damn fight down,and SOON as Cotto left Top Rank the fight was made...hell Arum turned the fight down when both were with Top Rank

And even as we speak Cotto is still not just a champion BUT THE LINEAL CHAMP AT 160..and MANNY IS STILL TOP 10 P4P..so kill your excuses

[AnimalisticMeth]

Gomez beat Zarate who was 52-0 with 51 kos.

[M Bison]

Blame Arum without any solid proof/evidence... typical petty pathetic behavior only a sad little Fl0mo could be capable of.