How Many Losses Does Mayweather Really Have?

[kiDynamite92]

Just Castillo 1. He whooped Pac and those who say otherwise don't know ***** bout boxing.

[Ryn0]

The only one that is really debatable is Castillo and it was close. So either 1 or none.

[BrometheusBob.]

Mayweather had a few close fights, some even very close fights that could have been scored for the other guy(actually only 1 imo) but never a true robbery. Every ATG has fights like that, few have actual robberies on their resume. Floyd isn't one of them.

True that, Ali-Norton III was probably more disputed than Mayweather-Castillo 1

[baya]

I voted he has one loss and that was the first Castillo fight. It was a close fight but I had Castillo winning by 2 points. It wasn't a robbery but in my mind it was a close loss for Mayweather and a close win for Castillo. I have seen all of Mayweather's fights and I think he won every fight but the first Castillo fight.

exactly how i had it. it was a clear loss IMO. mayweather took that fight too easy and it almost cost him. he didn't make the same mistake in the rematch ... btw kudos to mayweather for taking the immediate rematch, showed balls.

scoring fights is no small thing, i hate it that they took away a career high payday from castillo because of that but that's the sport at times.

[Pac=Duran]

0 because that's what his record says.

Idiocy. So bradley's win over Pac is legitimate? Paul Williams win over Lara is legitimate just because Wikpedia and boxrec have it on there? lol

[therealpugilist]

Idiocy. So bradley's win over Pac is legitimate? Paul Williams win over Lara is legitimate just because Wikpedia and boxrec have it on there? lol

Those were robberies


Pbf vs jlc 1 was no more than a 2 point swing or draw

Ive scored this fight dozens of times

Final punch numbers don't account for big rounds..... Jlc went loco his rounds but til mid to late he had to work his way into the fight



IMO this is my favorite fight of both

IMO.....these two were the best lightweights of 00-09

[Eff Pandas]

In my record book Mayweather is 47-0-1. I had the first Castillo fight 6-6.

I don't think there is any argument that Pacquiao & Cotto were robbed. The Pacquiao fight was pretty one sided & the Cotto fight while entertaining wasn't really that close if you just score the rounds & don't give Cotto extra bonus points for actually hitting Mayweather squarely more than perhaps anyone abit while getting hit squarely a whole lot more himself.

I think I could see an argument for Castillo I going Castillo's way & I could see Judah getting a much discussed controversial DQ win over Floyd. Beyond that most of the fights deemed close don't really seem that close to me. I did think Mayweather was gonna get robbed by De La Hoya when that split decision got announced, but I had that 8-4 Mayweather so I while I thought Oscar clearly lose I could see how he mighta been getting some points for being Oscar as tends to happen & he coulda stole it while not deserving it.

[Picazo]

No losses. The only fight I consider close enough to possibly entertain an argument is Castillo 1 and we saw how Castillo 2 went. Even so I've watched the first fight a handful of times and I can't see someone score it without a doubt for Castillo without having some sort of biased opinion against Floyd.

[_original_]

Only to Castillo in their first fight, even being a huge Floyd fan I just can't score that fight for him. Not a robbery per se, but Floyd should really be 1-1 against Castillo. Maidana 1 was close but I just can't see how one would have him winning 7 rounds, that's ridiculous. Oscar at best won 4/5 rounds, again, pretty absurd to state that Oscar was robbed and deserved 7 or even 6 rounds.


Cotto and Pacquiao both won 2 or 3 rounds each, the rounds they won put together wouldn't even equal a win against Floyd. lol

[b00g13man]

0. Castillo did come close though.