Comments Thread For: Thurman: Bad Shoulder or Not, Pacquiao Would've Lost!

[Tobi.G]

What are you talking about Man? Floyd won both Castillo fights with and without a bad shoulder. Pacquiao did not win his fight against Floyd.

Watch the fights man, watch them!

[M Bison]

Well post fight results shows Pac actually won with a bad shoulder and all.

Rounds 3 investigation



Rounds 1-2 invstigation


Rounds 6-7-8 investigation

Thank you for showing those videos that Youtuber is great, need more guys like that commentating less of these Floyd slurpers who can't give an unbiased view.

[jcpryor]

I see insecure FIomos are still out here telling us how Floyd "dominated" but he never hurt Manny, never scored a knocked down, didn't get the knock out they all said he'd get...

In fact, he was hurt himself in the fight and was completely neutralized offensively...

I think you people need to accept the fact that you can't just 'speak' a Pacquiao win into existence. I understand that you really wanted Pacquiao to win, but you don't always get what you want. This isn't a story book or a fairy tale. It's real life.

It's over. This was not a controversial fight, regardless of how much time you spend trying to convince yourself it was. Watching the fight in slow motion, freeze cam or with the volume turned off isn't going to change the outcome. Pacquiao lost. Accept it and move on. There's a lot more to life than your favorite fighter winning a boxing match.

Move on, Pacquiao fans. Maybe one day Floyd will give Pacquiao the rematch he wants. If that happens, fine. Just make sure that he is taking his daily dose of salt tablets leading up to the fight.

[ShoulderRoll]

Thurman saw what 99% of the rest of the world did: Floyd taking Pacquiao to school.

The other 1% are either know-nothing Pac fans or butthurt Mayweather haters.

[Spoon23]

Thank you for showing those videos that Youtuber is great, need more guys like that commentating less of these Floyd slurpers who can't give an unbiased view.

Truth will always come out eventually. Boxing fans now seeing who truly won that night and it's not the runner.

Oh and here is the epic round 4.

[MisanthropicNY]

Truth will always come out eventually. Boxing fans now seeing who truly won that night and it's not the runner.

Boxing has gone PC for a while now aka the "runner" wins unless completely dominated in the round...

Real boxing scoring where the fighter who does the most damage wins the round, I don't see how anyone can say Floyd did any better than a draw in this fight..People saying Floyd wipe out are just totally clueless to the entire point of boxing and competition...

[Spoon23]

Boxing has gone PC for a while now aka the "runner" wins unless completely dominated in the round...

Real boxing scoring where the fighter who does the most damage wins the round, I don't see how anyone can say Floyd did any better than a draw in this fight..People saying Floyd wipe out are just totally clueless to the entire of boxing and competition...

It has always been who connected the most and threw more lethal punches who wins the game, it's just that you can't win when a fighter his against is a protected boxer in vegas

Oh here is Round 7

The brilliance of Manny Pacquiao.

[MisanthropicNY]

It has always been who connected the most and threw more lethal punches who wins the game, it's just that you can't win when a fighter his against is a protected boxer in vegas

Oh here is Round 7

The brilliance of Manny Pacquiao.

TBH..I had the fight a draw when I first watched it..but then I realized how ridiculous the commentary and compubox was..watched it again had Pacquiao 7-5... Now that I'm watching it more and more..I think a case can be made for 8-4...although I'll stand with 7-5.. Pac definitely won the 2, 4, 6, 8, 9, 10, 12 (7 is debatable to me.)

[Gary Coleman]

Floyd Mayweather robbed Castillo out of a PTS victory, If you scored Floyd winning that fight you don't know **** about boxing.

But Floyd did, in fact, win.

I know him being undefeated hurts a lot of people to their core, but that's just something you're going to have to deal with.

[mathed]

Floyd and Pac both looked bad. Especially Floyd with his hugging and headlocking and all the shady stuff surrounding the fight. Mayweather is a cheater plain and simple, who the hell needs 2 saline IV drips to rehydrate 3 pounds? He was masking something illegal in his system but he has the money to pay everyone off.

Things like this is why he will never be remembered as TBE.

Thurman though......not sure what his angle is because he'd get mauled by Pac and outboxed by Mayweather, so either way, his career gets trainwrecked with a devastating loss.