Better resume Danny Garcia or Amir Khan

[El-blanco]

I'd say it's about even. They both beat feared punchers in maidan and Lucas, and they both lost to Peterson, don't care what the scorecard said. The tie breaker goes to Danny for the win though.

[BrometheusBob.]

Garcia and I don't think it's close.

[king4oranges]

Garcia had a better resume on paper but if you observed those fights he has been. He had some questionable decision

[trixx12]

Most feared man on the planet? Dunno about that.

The Matthysse and Khan wins were excellent but outside of that Garcia's resume isn't exactly outstanding especially considering the controversial decisions.

Khan has Kotelnik, a much fresher Paulie, a fresher Judah, Peterson (he won that fight) and Maidana.

Alexander is a decent win at Welterweight too whereas Garcia's only win at 147 has been a completely washed up, semi-retired Paulie. Julio Diaz and Algieri are better wins than that.

100 % agree with you.

[1hourRun]

Defeated Current Or Former World Champion In 8 Of Last 10

Paulie Malignaggi:
WBA World welterweight title
IBF World super lightweight title

Lamont Peterson:
WBA Super World super lightweight title
IBF World super lightweight title

Lucas Martin Matthysse: #1 contender @ 140

Zab Judah: HOF
WBC World welterweight title
WBA Super World welterweight title
IBF World welterweight title

Amir Khan:
WBA Super World super lightweight title
IBF World super lightweight title

Erik Morales:HOF
WBC World super featherweight title
IBF World super featherweight title
WBC World featherweight title
WBC World super bantamweight title
WBO World super bantamweight title

Kendall Holt:
WBO World super lightweight title

Nate Campbell:
IBF World lightweight title
WBA Super World lightweight title
WBO World lightweight title

[spytactics]

Decent thread. Hard for me to pick.

The answer is Garcia because he's Puerto Rican...duh!

[b00g13man]

Garcia for me.

[HughJass]

**** Garcia......His resume is ****ing shocking.I hate Khan and Garcia as equally.

I'm drunk and and "could" give a ****.Fat hotdog eating mofo

[MBE]

Easily Khan. He has softened up half of Garcias opponents for him, and we all know the version of Khan that fought Garcia was overlooking him and not focused. Not the real Amir.

[New England]

danny has a better resume. khan's speed might give more guys problems, but danny has an iron chin and power that can bail him out when his style isn't controlling the fight


danny's chin is rock solid, and he looks like his power is still good at 147. khan's always going to be a fast, athletic guy, but his chin keeps him one big shot away from a loss at all times.


hell, i feel at times like khan is one big punch away from being done with boxing. another knockout loss like prescott and khan will have some real thinking to do.