Golovkin in 80s-90s.

[RED REP]

Was Roy even beatable at that weight by anyone?
I'd give him a shot against everyone but Roy but who knows, styles make fights.

Indeed, 160 Jones Jr should be matched against Hagler and Robinson not Gennady.

[Killer_of_Sheep]

Would lose to Hopkins and Jones clearly.

I think Mccallum and Toney would be absolute wars that could go either way. But i'm favoring the old-timers in this one.

Toney was very good, but he gets vastly overrated. He could easily get outworked and wasn't a big puncher as people make him out to be, he wasn't that hard to hit too. Lesser fighters like Tiberi, Merqui Sosa and even Charles Williams (even tough he was KO'd) gave him plenty of trouble with pressure and activity.
Mccallum wasn't prime at MW and would probably get in the trenches with Golovkin. Would be an absolute war. But Mccallum durability is well proven while GGG's isn't.

GGG beats Kalambay and everyone else.

[SouthPawHitman]

That's it. End the thread right there because it will not see a better answer posted.

Yeah I'm pretty good at that

[Fists_of_Fury]

GGG hasn't fought anyone of substance yet to warrant this question IMO! The guys usually listed as GGG's best wins to date are Geale, Murray, and Macklin LMAO! I don't really see anything special at all about GGG except his power(although I'm not fully sold on that until he's VADA or USADA tested and he KO's a higher caliber opponent while being tested). Apparently I've watched more GGG fights than most of his fanboys... I still remember the Ouma fight lol. He's got 20 consecutive KO's doe. Only like 6 being rated within the top 10 of his weak division at the time lol. GGG's record and accolades so far I compare to putting glitter on a pile of shit. No matter how fancy you try and make it, it's still shit!


McCallum(underrated) vs GGG(overrated): McCallum by UD possible T/KO

Toney vs GGG: Toney by UD possible T/KO

Jones Jr. vs GGG: Jones Jr. by EASY 12rd UD possible T/KO and I'd lean toward the T/KO

Hopkins vs GGG: Hopkins by boring UD using his patented "veteran tacticz" like the right hand lead + headbutt combo.

Kalambay vs GGG: Kalambay by UD

I don't think GGG could hold his own against most of the better late 80's-early 90's boxers. GGG has done nothing to suggest that he could as of yet and he's 33 already lol! Until GGG beats a decent fighter I have everyone listed beating him. GGG would only have a slight punchers chance against some of them. Watch the Ouma fight please... the bloated and shot Ouma that GGG fought IMO is one of the best fighters he's faced so far.


Nunn vs GGG

Hagler vs GGG

Barkley vs GGG

Hearns vs GGG

Benn vs GGG

McClellan vs GGG

Eubanks vs GGG

Mugabi vs GGG

Solid post! Just wait for all the GGG is the greatest middleweight ever threads if he beats Lemieux LOL! Maybe we'll get lucky and Lemieux will beat him. I would die laughing. I still can't believe Golovkin vs Lemieux is on fucking PPV! I like GGG but his fanboys and his deluded team make it hard to root for him.