Ranking Resumes- Froch, Hatton, Margarito and Castillo

[KidDinamita]

For me Froch, Castillo, Hatton and Margarito. For me Margarito is still haunted with the plaster issue. Castillo have a great record as well but I think he had the exposure because he fought in the US and fought Mayweather when he was at his best.

Hatton also fought Vince Phillips, the guy that knocked out Kostya Tszyu, if you want to see a war you can also watch Ricky Hatton vs John Thaxton, was a real test for Hatton at the time. We all know that Hatton that fought in Vegas was fighting outside of his weight (due to his negligence between fights). He also fought at Madison Square Garden in his 2nd fight as a pro but went back to fight in the UK.

[Public_Enemy]

First off, Froch and Hatton are first ballot HOFers.

Margarito's legacy is tarnished, just like Mosley or Toney and none of them deserve the HOF.

Castillo should be in their considering the likes of Gatti are.

Now counting Margarito's win over martinez s a bit laughable as he was very green and only been in boxing a few years. Just naming a name doesn't make it a best win.

Like I've said over and over in this thread, I think they'll both get in. But some fans do debate whether they should so I made this list.

Mosley and Toney will get in. I don't think the steroid use will keep them out. Does Roy Jones not deserve HOF either? I think he does. Margarito was the toughest one to decide. People discredit his Cotto win but who really knows. I think as time passes he may sneak in. His case is not simple at all.

I think Castillo's resume is better than Hatton's.

Yes, Martinez was green. I know. I put Glen Johnson in Froch's list even though he was past it by the time they fought. He's not a big win for Froch but I threw him on the list anyway. Margarito doesn't have a lot of names but he has the best win of these four fighters.