Floyd Mayweather ATG status

[Robbie Barrett]

Biggest Fraud in Boxing history! He could have been a real good boxer. But he became the biggest hype job in boxing.

This thread's about Mayweather not Pacquiao. Doh........

[Baltimore]

So with the voting I guess its safe to say hes right around the 20th spot give or take one or two either way. I think that is very accurate spot for him and that is a great spot in history to be in.

I agree this is right around where I think he belongs. But honestly I've never taken the time to make an all-time p4p list so this is just where I feel he should be.

[BrometheusBob.]

Ahead of Pacquiao, where is that? Who the **** cares.

lol I'd have to imagine they're both top 50 (at least) but that's a separate topic from this thread

I put top 20 but it's debatable sounds like most people would have him 15-30. Too bad I didn't make more granular choices amongst the top 50 where there are a bunch of votes.

[Pu·gi·list]

In between 20-30

[RawDawgHasSpokn]

Top 20 because of his era. Best of his era though.

[Jcsuper]

Top 5 to 15 for me, and I am dead serious about it. In boxing, like all other sports, defensive guys are rated way too low in the atg lists. To me FLoyd is in the top 5 for the best defense of all time with guys like Pep, Benitez and Whitaker, he's undefeated in more thant 20 championship fights. He defeated the other best fighter of his era (Pacquiao), he has defeated three good undefeated fighters (Alvarez, Corrales and Hatton), he is a 5 weight class champion. So why does the best offensive fighters all automatically go in the top 20 but the best defensive fighters are getting bashed ?

People have always fall in love for kos. A guy like DUran can lose pretty much all the important fights of his career, quit in the middle of his biggest fight, but people will automatically put in top 10 cause he was an offensive genius...

[Cyberspace]

About 21-25 sounds realistic.