Who has more actual defeats?

[joesaiditstrue]

Lucas Matthysse

37 wins, none controversial
3 Defeats, 2 controversial

L-Danny Garcia (12 RD UD)
L-Devon Alexander (10 RD SD)
L-Zab Judah (12 RD SD)

Danny Garcia

30 wins, 3 controversial
0 defeats

W-Lamont Peterson
W-Mauricio Herrera
W-Ashley Theophane

It's interesting that both guys have the same number of controversial decisions. Only difference is that the more marketable, English speaking, Haymon fighter had them all in his favor

Poll coming

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Your forgetting about lucas getting tagged by Vivian Harris and getting saved by ref

[joesaiditstrue]

Your forgetting about lucas getting tagged by Vivian Harris and getting saved by ref

That wasn't controversial as Lucas was never losing that fight. Even if you wanna argue that it was up in the air the only copy of that fight online is absolutely terrible quality

[SeekDaGreat]

Lucas Matthysse

37 wins, none controversial
3 Defeats, 2 controversial

L-Danny Garcia (12 RD UD)
L-Devon Alexander (10 RD SD)
L-Zab Judah (12 RD SD)

Danny Garcia

30 wins, 3 controversial
0 defeats

W-Lamont Peterson
W-Mauricio Herrera
W-Ashley Theo phone

It's interesting that both guys have the same number of controversial decisions. Only difference is that the more marketable, English speaking, Haymon fighter had them all in his favor

Poll coming

Garcia beat Lamont. Lamont whooped Garcia's ass but literally gave away 5 of the first six rounds. And he lost 1,2 of the Last six. If anything draw would 've been the best case scenario for Peterson but just because he was the bigger stronger fighter and showed that late in the fight doesn't mean he won or the fight was co treversial. Fights are won by rounds. Not damage.

Just my two pennies.

[joesaiditstrue]

I had Danny winning the Peterson fight 115 113 and the Theophane fight though I need to watch it again. had him losing to Herrera 8-4

I thought lucas easily beat both Judah and Alexander

SO imo both should have one defeat

[Beercules]

Thought Danny lost to Lamont and Herrera.


Thought Lucas beat Zab and Alexander.

[Larry the boss]

Dont know and really dont care after all the **** Mattyhsee fans talked about him killing Garcia only for him to get swole up and dropped

[John Locke]

Matthysse 1, Garcia 2

[DeadLikeMe]

Dead man walking...decapitated...RIP Danny Garcia

[daggum]

Dont know and really dont care after all the **** Mattyhsee fans talked about him killing Garcia only for him to get swole up and dropped

so because you are annoyed by some fanboys you don't care about any other fight that happens in garcia's career? you are so annoyed that you pretend a foul is a knockdown? well i just have to say...that is pretty annoyed