Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Comments Thread For: “Fighting Words” — A Really Rough Night for Refereeing

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Comments Thread For: “Fighting Words” — A Really Rough Night for Refereeing

    by David P. Greisman - It is poetic yet unfortunate that Pat Russell’s career will end in the same manner as his final fight working as a boxing referee — slightly earlier than scheduled and distracting from much of what came beforehand.

    Russell had spent more than three decades as a referee and judge. Nearly all of his gigs came in California, though occasionally he traveled internationally to preside in the ring or score from ringside. He was now 67 years old and had said he would retire at the end of this year.

    This past Saturday, he was assigned to the main event at the StubHub Center in Carson, California, working the headline bout on HBO between welterweights Timothy Bradley and Jessie Vargas. For 11 rounds, two minutes and 50 seconds, Russell was largely inconsequential, there when necessary, not too much nor too little for what was otherwise a clean and competitive bout.

    That is precisely what referees seek to be: the third man in the ring not having an effect on the action provided by and attention given to the other two, the combatants. He does not want to be noticed except when needed. He is there to officiate, though not officiously.

    But then Russell made a mistake — likely an honest one, though still a big one. And while it was nowhere near the worst performance by a referee this past Saturday (more on that later), it is the one that is receiving the most debate and discussion among boxing fans outside of parts of Asia. [Click Here To Read More]

  • #2
    Good piece.

    Referees have a major obligation to observe and enforce rules fairly.
    Far too often we see refs actually influencing the tone of the fight.
    Whether it be having a blind eye to the hometown fighters holding or in England being far to eager to stop a fight benefiting the hometown fighter.

    Mistakes happen they are understandable but the larger problem seems to be corruption. Refs should behave the same in each fight, not customize their behavior based on whos fighting who.

    Comment


    • #3
      I was expecting part of this article to be about British referee Ian John Lewis, who also messed up on Saturday in the Fielding/Vera fight. He's been consistently the worst referee in boxing for the last 3 years and has many fans, writers and fighters calling for his sacking.

      Comment


      • #4
        Russell screwed up in the Bradley vs Provodnikov fight too. Provo should have been credited with a knockdown in the first round, but Russell called it a slip (Though Provo did give Bradley a little push). He then ordered Bradley to get up, & when he tried but fell down, Russell yelled at him to get up again. He got up and stumbled backwards into the ropes, which kept him from falling yet again. That's when he should have been given a count or the fight should have been stopped. Notice how slow Russlell counted when he finally credited Provo with a knockdown in the last round. The guy seems biased towards Bradley. Glad he's retiring.

        Last edited by SUBZER0ED; 06-29-2015, 11:02 AM.

        Comment


        • #5
          I remember a ref from California, Rosadilla was his name I think, he stopped a fight in Korea on a Korean and a crowd jumped into the ring. They started choking him with a towel, they dragged him to a corner and forced him to change his decision. It's not easy, just saying.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Corelone View Post
            I remember a ref from California, Rosadilla was his name I think, he stopped a fight in Korea on a Korean and a crowd jumped into the ring. They started choking him with a towel, they dragged him to a corner and forced him to change his decision. It's not easy, just saying.
            Could this be it? 11/10/93
            12/12 Eloy Rojas v Young-Kyun Park Featherweight
            Kwangmyung Gymnasium, Gwangmyeong City, South Korea
            WBA World featherweight title

            referee: Larry Rozadilla judge: Harmodio Cedeno 115-111, Lou Tabat 113-112, Chalerm Prayadsab 111-114

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by Mr.Daddy View Post
              Could this be it? 11/10/93
              12/12 Eloy Rojas v Young-Kyun Park Featherweight
              Kwangmyung Gymnasium, Gwangmyeong City, South Korea
              WBA World featherweight title

              referee: Larry Rozadilla judge: Harmodio Cedeno 115-111, Lou Tabat 113-112, Chalerm Prayadsab 111-114
              That's the ref. It was so bad, a film clip made it on the regular news. Big discussion after that about the stress on the officiating at a foriegn event. From threats of violence to bribes. I don't think anything came out of it.

              Comment


              • #8
                its about time human referees be replaced with robots or computers...

                Comment

                Working...
                X
                TOP