Who among these has already done enough to deserve entry to the IBHOF?

[Barcham]

My picks were Klitschko, Cotto, Marquez, Ward, and Bradley. I feel that what Ward did in the Super Six, and his win over Dawson made him a HOF'mer. As for my selection of Bradley, he is on the fence right now. The rest of his career could go either way. The win tomorrow night will mean nothing but he has to win. A couple more wins over A, B+ fighters, and he should get in.

If Ward had defeated Dawson at 175 and become a two division champion, I might agree with you. But he did not do that and Dawson was a drained shell of himself and does not even count as a quality fight in my eyes.

[BigAlexSand]

If Ward had defeated Dawson at 175 and become a two division champion, I might agree with you. But he did not do that and Dawson was a drained shell of himself and does not even count as a quality fight in my eyes.

Agreed. Personally didn't recognize Dawson.

[RED REP]

Cotto Klit Marquez.

Easiest poll of the year thus far.

[The Hammer]

If Ward had defeated Dawson at 175 and become a two division champion, I might agree with you. But he did not do that and Dawson was a drained shell of himself and does not even count as a quality fight in my eyes.

Agreed. And I don't count Ward's win over Kessler with those deliberate head butts that blinded Mikkel.

[The Hammer]

Marquez and Wlad from that list. No one else has done enough to warrant inclusion to the Hall of Fame. Only the absolute best of their generation should be inducted and it should not be based on popularity but only on achievements.

Cotto would need to fight Golovkin, win or lose, to gain admission in my book. Blatantly ducking a fighter gives anyone a black mark next to their name which must be erased to gain admission to the HOF in my eyes.

I agree, and no catch weight. He should defend his middleweight title at 160 at least once.

[RawDawgHasSpokn]

Marquez
Cotto
Klitschko
Tarver should go in for shocking the world with the RJJ KO

I agree 100%

[gamefrk]

Can't believe that drug cheat Tarver has 4 votes and Bradley only 9!

[Chrismart]

Wlad, JMM and Cotto.

[Ganondorf]

Marquez, Klit, Ward, Cotto

[Slyboots]

Wlad, Marquez, and Cotto.

Ward and Bradley are borderline, they each need another big win to get in IMO.