Chris Algieri V Kell Brook Poll

[gmc_rfc_06]

Not counting Manny and Floyd? Name 5 better

Brook
Thurman
Bradley
Maidana
Marquez
Porter
Khan

[PivotandRoll]

Brook
Thurman
Bradley
Maidana
Marquez
Porter
Khan

Khan? Really ? I don't know why I should even answer you after that.

Khan got a rip off win and everyone knows it.

Porter-Algeri are the same level for me. Both as proven as the other and both lost against real top level fighters.

Marquez has one fight left at most so I wasn't counting him

Okay he's top 6-7 at least. Hardly losing much ground.

[piojo del norte]

It's a close fight in my eyes. Regardless of how hard brook hits, I doubt he hits harder than provodnikov.

i think that in a way aswell but khan has no power and he landed shots that shook algeri up slightly, brook hit way harder then khan. I think it will be a dominating UD for brook.

[gmc_rfc_06]

Khan? Really ? I don't know why I should even answer you after that.

Khan got a rip off win and everyone knows it.

Porter-Algeri are the same level for me. Both as proven as the other and both lost against real top level fighters.

Marquez has one fight left at most so I wasn't counting him

Okay he's top 6-7 at least. Hardly losing much ground.

I had it 115-113 for Khan, but it was a terrible performance against a guy who was picked to make him look great.

Algieri had never fought at 147 before, I'm not even sure he should be ranked higher than Robert Guerrero let alone the likes of Porter who are far better than him.

[PivotandRoll]

I had it 115-113 for Khan, but it was a terrible performance against a guy who was picked to make him look great.

Algieri had never fought at 147 before, I'm not even sure he should be ranked higher than Robert Guerrero let alone the likes of Porter who are far better than him.

How is Porter better than these? A draw with Diaz and a win over a shot Paulie?

Porter better than Guerrero? Even I , a Kell fan who thinks he'd beat Thurman is happy to admit Robert is far more proven.

[Chrismart]

I think Algieri is a good fighter. That said, i'd pick Brook to beat him all day long.

He couldn't fight the same fight against Brook, that he did against Khan. He walked Khan down as he had no respect for Khan's power..he would have to have respect for Brook's power.

[gmc_rfc_06]

How is Porter better than these? A draw with Diaz and a win over a shot Paulie?

Porter better than Guerrero? Even I , a Kell fan who thinks he'd beat Thurman is happy to admit Robert is far more proven.

He beat Alexander up when he was champion, he splattered Paulie in 2 rounds to the extent of head damage and was a huge favourite against Brook...Algieri would rightfully be a huge underdog.

What has Guerrero done at WW? Beat a faded Berto? Embarrassed by Mayweather, trounced by Thurman, had a war with a Kamegai...

[PivotandRoll]

He beat Alexander up when he was champion, he splattered Paulie in 2 rounds to the extent of head damage and was a huge favourite against Brook...Algieri would rightfully be a huge underdog.

What has Guerrero done at WW? Beat a faded Berto? Embarrassed by Mayweather, trounced by Thurman, had a war with a Kamegai...

Jesus why do people bring up Alexander? What has he done in his entire career bar land two rather fortunate right uppercuts on Urango?

Berto is faded but Paulie isn't? We weren't talking about who would be the underdog though are we? We were talking about ranking.

[LacedUp]

Not counting Manny and Floyd? Name 5 better

Why wouldn't I count Manny & Floyd?

Anyway:

Floyd
Pacquiao
Bradley
Thurman
Guerrero
Porter
Khan
Brook
Maidana
Alexander
Rios
Sadam Ali
Diego Chaves
Broner

The list is literally infinitely long,

Hell even that kid Errol spence would beat the living sht out of Algieri.. There's probably more but I can't name them right now.

[LacedUp]

Khan? Really ? I don't know why I should even answer you after that.

Khan got a rip off win and everyone knows it.

Porter-Algeri are the same level for me. Both as proven as the other and both lost against real top level fighters.

Marquez has one fight left at most so I wasn't counting him

Okay he's top 6-7 at least. Hardly losing much ground.

You're joking.