Do the hamstrings supply more force to the punch than the quads or vice versa?
Collapse
-
Comment
-
-
I did answer. It's not about one over the other. It's about making it all work at once. Again, if you're trying to figure which is "used more" then you're doing it wrong. I'm not being a smart A--I'm telling you that you're missing the markComment
-
I believe the question itself is flawed. No offense intended.
Scientifically/Biomechanically, the legs do less to directly influence the power/forces generated than many of the posters in this thread seem to indicate. It would be more productive to look at the legs as contributors which, in addition to providing stability, serve to facilitate hip rotation (which is where power is optimally generated in any proximal-distal accelaration sequence i.e. punching,swinging, throwing).
I suppose all of that is just a fancy way of saying, if you took a toy propeller, one that just so happened to also have two protrusions at the bottom (similar to legs), how effectively could you use those protrusions to generate enough force to make the propeller fly? Chances are you'd just do what most kids instinctively do which is quickly spin the main shaft between your two hands and let go (let the 'spin main shaft between hands' jokes commence). Perhaps over-simplistic example, but the concept is exactly the same.
The pic in the original post shows a great example of rotational power of the hips. At no point is he showing 'leg drive' which would be indicated by an extension of the knee causing the leg to move in an upward direction. In fact, both legs are in a naturally flexed position at the time of contact of the punch.Comment
-
you dont know do you lol its not that im trying to do it that way for technique im asking to settle an argument with some1 elseComment
-
rocky uses alot of leg drive he was known for it, you can rotate the hips and punch or rotate and use the legs to supply drive in addition to hip rotationI believe the question itself is flawed. No offense intended.
Scientifically/Biomechanically, the legs do less to directly influence the power/forces generated than many of the posters in this thread seem to indicate. It would be more productive to look at the legs as contributors which, in addition to providing stability, serve to facilitate hip rotation (which is where power is optimally generated in any proximal-distal accelaration sequence i.e. punching,swinging, throwing).
I suppose all of that is just a fancy way of saying, if you took a toy propeller, one that just so happened to also have two protrusions at the bottom (similar to legs), how effectively could you use those protrusions to generate enough force to make the propeller fly? Chances are you'd just do what most kids instinctively do which is quickly spin the main shaft between your two hands and let go (let the 'spin main shaft between hands' jokes commence). Perhaps over-simplistic example, but the concept is exactly the same.
The pic in the original post shows a great example of rotational power of the hips. At no point is he showing 'leg drive' which would be indicated by an extension of the knee causing the leg to move in an upward direction. In fact, both legs are in a naturally flexed position at the time of contact of the punch.
we are just talking about the leg aspect of the punch in this question,Comment
-
-
Dude, I don't know how to make it much clearer to you--your question is flawed, the premise is flawed. It's like your asking the question: which works better in the water a car or a plane? And I'm telling you: a boatComment

Comment