How do you rate Marcos Maidana?

[Doctor_Tenma]

Solid fighter but at the same time overrated.

[UTEP]

I have him ranked #9 at welterweight.

Pac, Marquez, Brook, Floyd, Thurman, Alexander, Rios, and Bradley all beat him at 147 IMO.

EDIT: forgot about Amir Khan.

Amir Khan beats him too.

[Rapid Counter]

One thing is for sure. Maidana was rated higher by a lot of people before the Mayweather fights.

There was a time he was talked about like he was a killer on here.

I think he'd probably beat Alexander now. Good chance to beat Bradley. He'd beat Rios, and I like him vs. Marquez.

I could be wrong buy i think Alexander would whoop him again. Not that i think Alexander is a better fighter. I just think he will struggle against any southpaw. He looked totally confused against the south paw stance. Put him in with any orthodox fighter and he has a chance.

[Luilun]

I think he's a top 8-10 welterweight, no higher

But he kicked Floyds butt in first fight and left Floyd with lumps and bruises

[Hype job]

Hes ranked way to low by the ring. 9? You give Mayweather his hardest fight in years, and have 4 impressive wins leading up to that and you get shelved at 9? Robert Guerrero is ahead of you? PLease.

I think current Maidana walks through everyone at WW but Pac and May. Bradley fight would be good because hes tough and athletic but he can also be drawn in to wars.

Lol, the guy who got shutout by mediocre Alexander walks through everyone at WW but Pac and May.

Mayweather honeymoon effect is at work.

[Hype job]

Maidana is a Rios level opponent who Floyd struggled with, lol at people overrating him just because Floyd struggled with him.

[Da Machine]

Lol, the guy who got shutout by mediocre Alexander walks through everyone at WW but Pac and May.

Mayweather honeymoon effect is at work.

Im not even going to try and justify it to you. Maidanas simply a better fighter since he got together with Garcia.

[LoadedWraps]

Is he a better fighter now after his two bouts with Floyd Mayweather, Has he learned from those fights or has it taken something out of him

Do you rate him as a top 5 Welterweight or do you rank him lower

Top 5 WW without question. There are only 3 better than him in the divison: Floyd, Bradley, and Brook, and depending on how the fight plays out, Bradley and Brook could lose to him. Prime Manny would be above him but this version of Manny would be in serious trouble against a lion like Maidana.

[Hype job]

Im not even going to try and justify it to you. Maidanas simply a better fighter since he got together with Garcia.

Lol Argentino crybaby

Broner is shet and did not belong at WW.

Maidana is slow as a MF and is Rios level, people just overrating him because he gave Floyd 2 tough fights.

Shut out by that shet fighter Devon Alexander lol, Alexander is f**king SHET LOL.

[John Locke]

Really?

Name 8 WW's better than Maidana.

Pac, Floyd, Thurman, Bradley, Brook, Porter, Khan, Marquez

I think that's the top 8, you can take Marquez out depending on how shot he is