Could a prime Sugar Shane clean out current WW?

[Szef]

That's what happens when you get in a fight. Manny was put to sleep twice by two cab drivers. Hopkins loss to Jermaine Taylor twice.

Is Shane Mosley an average fighter, yes or no?

[Robbie Barrett]

My bad I meant 13-9-1. He had 34 career wins at LW not 32. I went back and counted.

4 of those losses and the draw weren't at WW and the guys he did lose to at WW were ATG/HOF fighters not average fighters. Nothing average at all.

[jas]

Now that you've removed that ridiculous P4P list you use to rock, I'm really digging your sig.

Thanks for reminding me.

Gonna add it back in now.

Gonna look something like this:

1. Hopkins
2. PAC
3 rigo
4. Bradley
5. Thurman
6. Ggg
7. Roman
8. Kovalev
9. Mayweather
10. Wlad

[Outwest Exp 355]

4 of those losses and the draw weren't at WW and the guys he did lose to at WW were ATG/HOF fighters not average fighters. Nothing average at all.

So are you saying he was better at WW than LW? No matter how you try and explain the man was a much better LW. It's not a knock it's just the simple truth.

[Szef]

Thanks for reminding me.

Gonna add it back in now.

Gonna look something like this:

1. Hopkins
2. PAC
3 rigo
4. Bradley
5. Thurman
6. Ggg
7. Roman
8. Kovalev
9. Mayweather
10. Wlad

This mothe****er knows his boxing, no doubt about it.

[bojangles1987]

So are you saying he was better at WW than LW? No matter how you try and explain the man was a much better LW. It's not a knock it's just the simple truth.

He wasn't a much better lightweight, if he fought the level of competition at LW that he fought at WW and above he would have lost then, too.

[Scott9945]

No .

Besides, he would come up dirty in a drug test

Shane has never failed a drug test. The only reason he is associated with it was that he showed up on a BALCO list and was forced to testify in front of a grand jury.

[lfc19titles]

prime mosley was on drugs, that is a 100 percent fact

the answer is yes, a prime mosley on drugs would have defeated the current wws easily, he would have also beaten a prime may and pac

[Ray*]

Shane has never failed a drug test. The only reason he is associated with it was that he showed up on a BALCO list and was forced to testify in front of a grand jury.

So what if he never failed a test? The fact was Mosley was on performance enhancing drugs, boxing testing procedure is one of the worse in sport.

[M Bison]

Clean the entire division out?
Ofcourse he wouldn't, don't be silly he came across certain fighters before in his career and he got shown up and that was in his prime there is enough talent in the WW division to cause him a lot of problems and likely enough to hand him a couple of defeats.

I'd give Thurman a good chance of doing it and also Maidana and Khan.
We can forget about the obvious Pacquiao and Mayweather, they'd beat him regardless.