Sooooooo How does your WELTERWEIGHT RANKINGS Look like after last night?

[jmrf4435]

I think Brook, Thurman, Maidana, Khan, and floyyd, pac all beat Marquez--Really good list. I would have Maidana and Marquez switched around, and khan and brook. Brook beat a caveman in Porter, no ring strategy and relies on athleticism to win fights. Uggh part of me might rank Khan ahead of Bradley after last night...

1. Floyd
2. Pacquiao
3. Bradley
4. Brook
5. Khan
6. Thurman
7. Marquez
8. Maidana
9. Porter
10. Guerrero

[SAN D13GO VILLAN]

Why is brook so high on some list, he beat porter in a close fight, he has skills but his resume still needs work, just my opinion.

[KayDub]

I think Porter and Bradley get ranked too high, as well as Marquez. This is just my opinion at this time, it's a really hard list to make since so few of the top 10 have faced others on the top 10, especially recently.

1 & 2 is between Pacquiao and Mayweather
3 Khan
4 & 5 is between Thurman and Maidana
6 Brook
7 Bradley
8 Guerrero
9 Chaves
10 Marquez

REALLY hard list to make since so few of the top fighters have been fighting eachother. It really just hit me how bad matchups have been since this is the case.

It's questionable if Thurman is as high as I put him since he hasn't faced anyone "elite" but I think he's the goods.
I think Maidana beats a lot of the top 10 on a good night. I'm hoping for a Thurman Maidana matchup soon.
Chaves I put so high because of how he did against Bradley, Rios, and Thurman.
Khan is so high because of his showing against Alexander, but I think he struggles with Orthodox fighters so he could get dropped off that list quickly.
Marquez is so low because he's a pretty small guy and getting up there in age.
Brook is so high for beating Porter easily, though he's another I could see starting to drop.
Bradley doesn't seem like a real welterweight. He's small, not really impressive at anything besides his heart, but he's still in the top 10.
Guerrero also still deserves a stop in the top 10 but I could see him being replaced.
I don't put Porter on the list because he hasn't done enough and doesn't look that good. Just a swarmer and I think he'll continue to get beat by top 10 fighters.

[JakeTheBoxer]

1. Floyd
2. Pac
3. Brook
4. Khan
5. Marquez
6. Maidana
7. Thurman
8. Bradley
9. Alexander
10. Porter