SRL vs PBF

[Bahamut Zero]

Who could've won? Let's say at 140-above.

[JuicyJuice]

I've never seen Robinson fight at 147, we only have footage of his middleweight days.

And Mayweather isn't a natural 140lber, he had to started doing weight-training to get up to 140 and then 147.

[JuicyJuice]

I'll say this though - Mayweather is more skilled than Ray Robinson was (based on everything I've seen of both of them). Infact, Mayweather is probably the most skilled fighter I've ever seen.

[Bahamut Zero]

Sugar Ray Leonard dude!

[JuicyJuice]

Sugar Ray Leonard dude!

I'm officially an idiot.

[marvdave]

I have a motto..never pick against SRL

[The Wire]

I would have to pick Sugar Ray Leonard, purely because Mayweather hasnt truly proven himself yet. He needs to fight at a higher level and attack true world titles and not belts. So by this I mean that at 140 he should have chased Kostya Tszyu and not Arturo Gatti, and at 147 he should have chased Baldomir and not Judah, or at least waited to see if Judah could beat Baldomir in a rematch and mark time fighting someone like Shane Mosley or Margarito. He tends to pick the easy fights, a criticism you simply cant lay at SRL's door. I think that Leonard would beat him just on his experience, let alone his skill level.

[GunStar]

I'll say this though - Mayweather is more skilled than Ray Robinson was (based on everything I've seen of both of them). Infact, Mayweather is probably the most skilled fighter I've ever seen.

I agree with you JuyJuy, Mayweather is the most skilled fighter I've ever seen. In my eyes Leonard was the most skilled until I saw Floyd.

Mayweather is the most complete fighter I've ever seen & I've seen just about every fighter. I will still put Leonard over Floyd in my all time list. Maybe Mayweather will surpass Leonard's greatness one day, who knows.

[Mr. Ryan]

For Mayweather to stand in there and beat Leonard, he would have to fight the fight of his life. Ray Leonard is too skilled and has much more heart for Mayweather. I see this fight being a replay of the Benitez fight, with Leonard stopping Mayweather late at the end of a tough fight.

[GunStar]

I would have to pick Sugar Ray Leonard, purely because Mayweather hasnt truly proven himself yet. He needs to fight at a higher level and attack true world titles and not belts. So by this I mean that at 140 he should have chased Kostya Tszyu and not Arturo Gatti, and at 147 he should have chased Baldomir and not Judah, or at least waited to see if Judah could beat Baldomir in a rematch and mark time fighting someone like Shane Mosley or Margarito. He tends to pick the easy fights, a criticism you simply cant lay at SRL's door. I think that Leonard would beat him just on his experience, let alone his skill level.

Lol, you rather see PBF fight Baldy then Zab