Maidana is top 5

[Easy Work.]

This dude is a beast in the ring no doubt..You really cant take credit away from him by losing to the best and that is Floyd. IMO only floyd is the one able to contain him and thats not bad at all.

He shouldnt have taken the floyd fight so early, he really should have continued to knock guys out because he is just different he is gritty and he is a dirty fighter that will knock anyone out. In my opinion he beats pacman today easily, his only flaw is a really good defensive fighter like floyd and floyd is one of a kind so that speaks for itself.

Are you guys still fans of maidana because i just watched the broner fight in its entireity and dude is impressive.....i really think hes the best next to floyd and who is he fighting next btw?

IMO he beats pac, he beats broner in a rematch and beats down guys like timothy bradley.

[John Locke]

I got Maidana at #10 at 147

[Beater_of_ass]

No, he just sucks and only looked good against Floyd because he's getting old fast.

[Larry the boss]

wow............

[Divine Hammer]

he should be ranked at the bottom of welterweight.

only notable win at welterweight is broner hype job. he lost to alexander too.

he's an exciting fighter with a warrior spirit, but his resume at welterweight and his skill level doesn't justify him being near the top 5.

[megadeth]

Pac most likely decisions him unless he walks into something or gets forced into an a closer quarters fight.
Thurman Ko's him
Tim decisions him
I even think Broner beats him in the rematch.

[LouIE G]

Pac would wreck maidana, he would probably beat broner doe...and timmy would box his socks off.

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

people underestimate maidana with garcia in his corner

[hoo's necks]

Maidana is a real fighter. Not a hypejob by any means. He earned his spot in the mix. In 2009 he was brought in as food for Victor Ortiz. Ever since then I knew he was real... to face that kind of adversity (multiple knockdowns) and still comeback to win. Not even Floyd has done that. Just being real. El Chino is underrated.

[hoo's necks]

he should be ranked at the bottom of welterweight.

only notable win at welterweight is broner hype job. he lost to alexander too.

he's an exciting fighter with a warrior spirit, but his resume at welterweight and his skill level doesn't justify him being near the top 5.

But you gotta rank him higher since whooping Floyd's ass. If not you're just a hater. Go to the Hater's Ball.