Is Donaire HoF worthy?

[Larry the boss]

How many fighters in the history of the sport have won titles in 4(don't count interim titles) divisions? 6 titles in 4 divisions

[Sugar Adam Ali]

2nd ballot HOF for me

Well put,,,

He isn't a first ballot guy like oscar, Floyd, Roy but he is a hall of famer

[IIG]

Donaire has been a hall of famer for a while in my eyes. No doubt that he gets in.

[JJRod]

hes definitely a borderliner. 5 time division champ, fought great competition , but was also inactive for large parts of his career, and the year he won foty his competition was suspect.

Never the less I hope Donaire doesn't decide to call it quits. He's still one of my favorite guys to watch. He can go back down to 122 fight fight Frampton, LSC maybe Mares

[miron_lang]

Is Gatti in?

Donairre had accomplished so much more than Gatti.

[LacedUp]

Of course he is. No question about it.

[Pain~Lucy]

lol cant believe some 10 idiots voted no, what did you see in donaire his 2 loses? lol

[DoktorSleepless]

Why would "Rigo worshipers" say no? Wouldn't if better for Rigo to have a HOF fighter on his resume?

Because the Rigo accountants want Donaire to give Rigo a rematch, they claim Donaire isn't truly HOF until he beats Rigo.

[puga]

I always felt he was the 2012 FOTY by default, because he was the busiest top guy. It was a case of quantity over quality. Vasquez, Mathebula, old Arce, and old Nishioka don't exactly scream out amazing year. It's pretty much what GGG does every year yet people call him overrated. Marquez' historic KO of Pacquiao craps all over those wins by a mile.

Jmm deserved ko the the year but definitely not fighter of the year....jmm looked very beatable up until the ko , in which was the cause of pac making a huge mistake rather than jmm .setting it up.....

[damit305]

Very much so. An accomplished fighter. Hope to see him soon.