Why are more people calling for a Danny-Lucas rematch than a Broner-Chino rematch?

[FerFAL]

I hope Maidana plans to keep fighting if he loses to Floyd again, I would like to see this rematch develop again. It was too much fun. I was encouraged to hear Broner mention it as a goal last night. Hopefully the right time this time, with a couple of fights at 140 first. Give himself a better shot at it.

Unless there's some good money involved he doesnt seem that interested. Before he got the rematch he said he either fought Floyd again or he retired, looked as if he meant it too. Chino is fun to watch, I hope he keeps fighting for a few more years.

[MotorCityJaguar]

Probably because Garcia-Matthysse was relatively close

This


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[Pugilist95]

It's simple really, Garcia vs Matthysse (ignore the thread I made, I was trolling) was competitive whereas Chino completely dominated Broner.

[Butt stuff]

I still believe a rematch is warranted after Maidana loses to Floyd in September.

Showtime Boxing Presents

Adrien Broner vs Maidana II

-

Matthysse vs Garcia II

-

Porter vs Thurman

Hell, you can put it on PPV and make it a "knock out kings" card.

This is the first post I've seen you make on here that isn't race baiting, hateful and it actually makes sense- this would be a fantastic card.

[SlySlickSmooth]

This thread sucks. OP sucks.

"Danny won a wide decision" It was a close clear cut decision.

"If this fight was 14 rounds Broner would of.." WTF????

[Agent Mulder]

I can only imagine OP'S basement walls.

[#1Assassin]

people dont like broner and dont want to see him get a chance to avenge his lone defeat.

chino-broner 2 makes a lot more sense imo. broner unlike matthysse can make adjustments and fight a different fight and even if it went the same way it was a far more entertaining fight than garcia-matthysse. finally broner was defending champion when they fought the first time, unlike matthysse who was challenging DSG.

edit: i see a lot of people are pretending maidana dominated broner which was far from the case. he won the fight for sure but it was very competitive and broner had plenty of moments. but i guess these are the same people who want to pretend broner lost to malignaggi and ponce de leon. lol.

[Medinabcheatin]

Gaydanna cheated fo that fight and urrbody know it. They jus wanna see Broner lose and its cawse he gotta "certain" compleckshun.

[PR13]

Let's go over some simple facts first.

Firstly, it's common knowledge that Lucas was massively hyped and was the favorite to win in his fight against Lucas. In fact it was literally set in stone that Lucas was going to KO Danny at least according to casual fans, but more objective fans knew otherwise. Then comes fight night and the boy gets dismantled and out boxed. Clear cut wide decision for Danny who not only managed to badly hurt Lucas but dropped him too. This is simply not a fight that screams "rematch" at all, yet I see more fans calling for it over a Broner-Maidana rematch.


Now let's look at the facts between the Maidana Broner fight and the events that occurred after the fight. This was more of an even fight among boxing pundits and fans across the board. We all saw what happened, and in the end Chino came out victorious. Of course we can talk about su****ious substances given to him in the corner and questionable roughhousing tactics but that's for another topic. Both Broner and Maidana got touched up in that fight and both were pretty torn. I believe Maidana claimed that Broner was one of the hardest punchers he's faced, and he did admit he was hurt to the body and the head a few times, including in the last round. Close but clear decision for Maidana simply due to the knockdowns, his boxing wasn't incredible or anything spectacular. Had that fight been a 14 rounder, it wouldn't shock me the outcome was much different as Broner's pace was picking up dramatically.

So what happened after the fight? Broner immediately called for a rematch. And what was the response given to him by Team Maidana? He claimed that his wife was having a baby and wouldn't be ready for a rematch anytime soon. Yet along comes Floyd and that baby was no longer cared about, because that fight was on in an instant. Basically Maidana wasn't "available" for Broner's call for a rematch but he damn near packed his bags for the US when Floyd's people gave him the call. That's a dirty move by him.

Do you agree that Broner vs Maidana is more credible for a rematch than Danny vs Lucas, a rather one sided boxing affair to which we already know the outcome to?

I'll pay to watch Maidana/Broner 2... Garcia beat Lucas nicely, doesn't need a rematch.

[M Bison]

people dont like broner and dont want to see him get a chance to avenge his lone defeat.

chino-broner 2 makes a lot more sense imo. broner unlike matthysse can make adjustments and fight a different fight and even if it went the same way it was a far more entertaining fight than garcia-matthysse. finally broner was defending champion when they fought the first time, unlike matthysse who was challenging DSG.

edit: i see a lot of people are pretending maidana dominated broner which was far from the case. he won the fight for sure but it was very competitive and broner had plenty of moments. but i guess these are the same people who want to pretend broner lost to malignaggi and ponce de leon. lol.

His lone defeat?

He lost to Quintero and Ponce De Leon but did those two get their chance for a rematch...?
No the sly management team tried to ignore the fact their boy got beat.