When was the last time Khan beat a top ten p4p ranked opponent?

[Lullaby]

Are some people trying to compare Khan's resume with Maidana?

there's absolutely No freaking comparison Khan's win over Kotelnik alone beats anyone on Maidana's resume if Maidana can get a crack at Mayweather but beating someone like Broner so should Khan.

[John Locke]

No, but seriously, tell me how Collazo is a good win for Khan.

Maidana beat an ancient Morales, so that win and Khan's win over an ancient Barrera are comparable.

It was his first fight at 147 (proper) and Collazo was a top 10 guy.

Indeed they are comparable, the difference is Khan beat Barrera decisively, Maidana struggled against Morales and just about managed to get the W. Also the Barrera Khan beat was at lightweight, a weight far more comfortable for Barrera than 140 is for Morales.

The bottom line is Maidana's best win is Soto Karass, for a guy who's been around for so long and been given opportunities against some top guys, that's not good enough.

[Lullaby]

Maidana is a one dimentional brawler at best, can't believe Maidana fans are criticizing Khan and thinks he's not worthy of a Floyd fight but Maidana already has LOST to Floyd and getting a shot again. *signs* also khan already beat Maidana.

[Beater_of_ass]

You said he hadn't faced anyone in the top 10 of his division. Changing your tune now?

No, I knew he did but I wasn't sure exactly who was top 10 when he beat them, and I was trying to get a rile out of the Khannies. Given that its basically a bunch of journeymen it isn't anything to write home about. Judah even being in the top 10 when he faced Khan is ****ing laughable, so to me he beat 2 guys in the top 10 of his division in 30 or so pro-fights, big ****ing deal.

[VG_Addict]

Judging by his P4P list, I don't think Booty Dew even knows what P4P means. He had the Klits as #1, FFS.

The whole point of P4P is to determine who's the best regardless of weight classes.

[Beater_of_ass]

According to March 2014, Luis Collazo was ranked #2 by the WBA, but now I'm assuming sanctioning body rankings don't count right?

You actually believed Collazo was the #2 WW at the time? I don't know whats worse the ranking or you actually believing it.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

No, I knew he did but I wasn't sure exactly who was top 10 when he beat them, and I was trying to get a rile out of the Khannies. Given that its basically a bunch of journeymen it isn't anything to write home about. Judah even being in the top 10 when he faced Khan is ****ing laughable, so to me he beat 2 guys in the top 10 of his division in 30 or so pro-fights, big ****ing deal.

Gets owned. Backtracks heavily

[Larry the boss]

Never?????????

[Beater_of_ass]

Gets owned. Backtracks heavily

It was sarcasm... but fine you owned me. His resume is still absolute ****.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

It was sarcasm... but fine you owned me. His resume is still absolute ****.

His resume at 140 was very good for a young fighter. He fought pretty much everyone except Tim Bradley who avoided him.