Does anyone here have an ATG list?

[New England]

I wish I could post one but I am not educated on any fighters pre-1980's.
I have seen the movie Cinderella Man and I watched Ali-Frazier 1.
That's about the extent of my boxing knowledge pre-1980's so for me I can't even try to put together an ATG list yet.

i don't know if you're trying to joke, but this was extremely funny either way. good sh#T.

[Croyd]

i don't know if you're trying to joke, but this was extremely funny either way. good sh#T.

yeah I'm joking around but I still don't know much about boxing pre-80's.
There's Ali of course but Ali has biographies and moves made about him every year or so,everyone knows a little about Ali.

I also watched a biography on Jack Johnson,he was impressive.
Sort of like the Klitschko of the early 1900's, nobody matched him in size.
Watching his bio , I was surprised he wasn't assassinated,lynched , or just out right murdered. He carried around the largest set of balls.

[SBleeder]

Here's my most recent attempt at a list:
1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Henry Armstrong
3. Harry Greb
4. Ezzard Charles
5. Joe Gans
6. Muhammad Ali
7. Willie Pep
8. Sam Langford
9. Benny Leonard
10. Archie Moore
11. Joe Louis
12. Roberto Duran
13. Carlos Monzon
14. Eder Jofre
15. Jimmy Wilde
16. Sugar Ray Leonard
17. Tony Canzoneri
18. Bob Fitzsimmons
19. Pernell Whitaker
20. Gene Tunney
21. Wilfredo Gomez
22. Larry Holmes
23. Jimmy McLarnin
24. Marvin Hagler
25. D1ck Tiger

[Weltschmerz]

i consider the "ATG" the top 100 fighters in history based on accomplishments and ability. what's most important is figuring out a way to evaluate, give value to, and compare "who was beaten, and when."

Yes, but for me is always the issue of 'who beat who'. How do we establish in what way past opponents of the champs were greater than today's contenders? This is where it, IMO, just comes down to favoritism and subjectivity in the end. There is no real point to this debate, really.

[toooooool]

greatest 3 fighters to ever live

robinson
armstrong
ali

I'm the biggest Ali fan their is but i'm starting to think he is off the top 10
list...He lost the biggest fight of his career to Frazier and he also lost to
a guy who only had 7 pro fights in Spinks...I'm starting to think Mayweather
is right;Every fight in your career you are judged on!!..we can't count some
fights and not others in a career..every fight has equal weight..Period.
Added to any top 10 list should be Marciano,Lopez,Calzaghe,Mayweather
...They never lost..