Just rewatched Matthysse-Judah

[vman075]

First off I can't take anymore Cotto-Martinez threads, so I figure I'll throw a different one out there.

How did everyone score it. I know most people think the Alexander fight was the clear robbery, but imo this one was the worse decision of the two. I scored Alexander-Matthysse 5-5 but I think Lucas won bc of the knockdown. This one I scored 8-4 Lucas plus a kd, maybe 7-5 plus a kd.

I gave Matthysse 3,4,5,6,9,10,11,12 and a kd
I gave Judah 1,2,7,8
5 and 7 were close, I still give the fight to Lucas even if you give both to Zab. Lederman gave Zab round 9, not sure what he did to deserve that. The best I can give judah is 5 rounds. All Judah did in this was paw with his jab and then would throw punches only in the last 30 second of the round.

What did you guys score it? I read the comments on youtube and some people gave Zab the fight; if anybody here scored it Zab, i'd love to know which 7 rounds you gave him.

[Spray_resistant]

Matty beat Alexander close but clear, it was a 10 rd fight and a kd means alot......no way you can give Alexander 6 rds for even a draw forget 7 for the win.

[techliam]

Alexander fight was a complete robbery to me

But I thought Judah edged Matthysse, 114-113. I thought this was an either way fight that gets labelled a robbery because of the Alexander fight, when I don't believe it is. I cant remember the rounds, only the score, but I will happily come back with the rounds if I rewatch that fight

[Foreign Soil]

Basically, a lot of crap rounds with neither guy doing much, then Matthysse starts having a few dominant rounds to end the fight, while Judah never had a dominant round nor really a clear round.

[Russian Crushin]

If you count punches landed, Lucas clearly won

[Lalaland]

I scored it a draw,

[RiC-DiC]

cant remember what my score was bu ti had it for Judah mainly because matteesey dint throw enough punches as a challenger should and hes from argentena so u simply cant let him win./

[Russian Crushin]

cant remember what my score was bu ti had it for Judah mainly because matteesey dint throw enough punches as a challenger should and hes from argentena so u simply cant let him win./

There's a threshold for how many punches a challenger must throw? How many is that?

He clearly landed more and better punches

[Da Machine]

People over scored Judahs jab early in the fight. It was never really landing much.

Alexander fight was a robbery.

People forget how much he has improved since those fights also.