Where is Cotto on your p4p list?

[Kuyukut]

i'd put cotto @ #5, about 2 level up where fraud jr is.

[soul_survivor]

Top 10?

Just dethroned Sergio at 160. Amazing

He's gotta be in the top 10 now, no matter where he was post Mayweather/Trout. P4P is based on a lot of things but one of the major factors is achievements and who a this best, would beat who without the issue of weight.

If that Cotto turned up against anybody on the planet, he'd beat most guys except probably Pac, Floyd, Ward, Wlad and maybe a handful of others.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Not on mine, but he is an honorable mention, and i wont argue if someone has him on it..

Him and hopkins are about the toughest ones to judge and rank....


I took serg off my p4p list after the murray fight, and everyone thought it was nonsense but the dude too old to be effective vs top guys anymore...

Cotto has a great win over serg, but not enough to make him p4p,, but i can see him being 8-10 roughly

[Beercules]

Bump.



Great win

[kombayn]

1.) Mayweather
2.) Klitschko
3.) Ward
4.) Pacquiao
5.) Cotto
6.) Marquez
7.) Rigondeaux
8.) Hopkins
9.) Froch
10.) Golovkin