Which "Magic Man" Had the Best Career?

[Awesome-O]

Not who was the best in their prime (clearly starling), but who had the best career?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Tarver had the better career..

Wins over everyone at lhw including 2 over Roy, plus glen johnson..

The rocky movie

Headlined major pay per views vs jones, Hopkins

Had a good announcing career til the roids bust...


I thinks tarver had a great career considering how limited he was as a fighter

[DreamMerchant12]

Tarver, even though I hated him for KO'ing RJJ. Still a beast though.

[Kingjames6Flee]

Tarver, even though I hated him for KO'ing RJJ. Still a beast though.

lol @ your sig

[Divine Hammer]

david blaine

[Awesome-O]

I threw in Malignaggi because I like malignaggi, but what is he doing with more votes than Starling?

[Ham Porter]

U WOT M8?????

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I threw in Malignaggi because I like malignaggi, but what is he doing with more votes than Starling?

Because this forum is filled with idiots that don't know boxing history, even recent history

[Guest]

I went with Tarver but you could easily argue Starling.

Tarver a lot of times caught guys late in their careers and he really didn't get going until he was almost 35 years old.



Jones victory is too big to ignore though Starling beat good guys too.

He just doesn't have that kind of name on his resume.
He did ko an undefeated Olympic killer in Breland, and beat some other names.

And no shame in losing to Michael Nunn who was fantastic at his best, and Curry.

[Awesome-O]

Tarver
Starling
Malignaggi