If Broner was the same size as Maidana, could Maidana win?

[lolpz]

Well floyd is taller, and have longer reach then Maidana, so he is ecentially `bigger`

Maidana may weigh more, but he looks soft and watery, if maidana came in at the same level of dryness as floyd he would properly weigh in at 140.

The weigh in at the same weight, just because maiden goes on a water and eating maraton pre fight means very little.
It properly does more damaged then good

Looks like its you that is the ****** ****

you are a ****ing dumbass. Maidana dehydrated to 146.5 for the weigh in, then rehydrated to 165. Mayweather was on weight for the weigh in already 145.5 pounds, and ate his way up to 148 the day of the fight. You are even more clueless than the other guy holy crap.

[110110110]

you are a ****ing dumbass. Maidana dehydrated to 146.5 for the weigh in, then rehydrated to 165. Mayweather was on weight for the weigh in already 145.5 pounds, and ate his way up to 148 the day of the fight. You are even more clueless than the other guy holy crap.

WTF ?????

Maidana looks ****ing fat at his normal weight, he properly like 25 % body fat, floyd is ripped to pieces.

You put way to much emphasis on rehydration, You don't grow 15 pounds of bone and muscle over night.

And the numbers don't li

Stats for Maidana
height / 170cm
reach / 175cm

Stats for floyd

height / 173cm
reach / 183cm

Floyd is a much bigger man period

Is Odlanier Solis a bigger man then Vitaly ?, no he is fatter dumb ****

If you weigh in at the correct weight that is all that matters.


You really need a reality check

[Luilun]

If Broner was as big as Maidana...............size wize. could Maidana still win?

Not seying bon was robbed or nothing but jut saying maidnaa won his fights cuz he a giant in a small man's division. he gave floyd a tuff fight too becuse of size. Madian was 168 pounds so that's super middle weight. He should be fighting Ward./Froch etc etc.

Actual Madaina was 165 Broner got a taste of his own medicine Broner was 154 pounds fighting lightweights

[boliodogs]

Maidana would win. Broner is not smaller than Maidana. He is probably bigger if we are talking about lean muscle weight. Take a good look at the photos of them in the ring together. It's easy to see that Maidana is carrying much more body fat than Broner.

[Da Machine]

Broner is every bit as big as Maidana and looked it in the ring.

[MaskedMurderer]

If Carlos Molina was the same size as Broner who would win?
If Gavin Rees was the same size as Broner who would win?
If Eloy Perez was the same size as Broner who would win?

If Broner was the same size as Ponce de Leon would he have won much more decisive, and not have a lot of people say Ponce got robbed?

This fool straight up OWNED the OP with this post.

[lolpz]

WTF ?????

Maidana looks ****ing fat at his normal weight, he properly like 25 % body fat, floyd is ripped to pieces.

You put way to much emphasis on rehydration, You don't grow 15 pounds of bone and muscle over night.

And the numbers don't li

Stats for Maidana
height / 170cm
reach / 175cm

Stats for floyd

height / 173cm
reach / 183cm

Floyd is a much bigger man period

Is Odlanier Solis a bigger man then Vitaly ?, no he is fatter dumb ****

If you weigh in at the correct weight that is all that matters.


You really need a reality check

I've never in my life seen some **** like this. What in the actual **** am i reading? The person i'm replying to thinks that being taller and having longer arms makes you bigger than someone else. I'll pray for you.

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

thank you manny and floyd for attracting these fans to boxing. and when i say thank you i mean **** you

[110110110]

I've never in my life seen some **** like this. What in the actual **** am i reading? The person i'm replying to thinks that being taller and having longer arms makes you bigger than someone else. I'll pray for you.

Your post don't make much sense, but are you really soo braindead, that you are trying to dispute a mathematical fact ?

I gave a you the facts, explained why maidana issent `bigger`then floyd, only heavier on fight night, not because he is `bigger`, but because he holds more fat and water in his body.

It seems to me that you think that all there is to boxing is who weighs the most on fight night.

Well floyd is one of the very very very few boxers that weigh the same year round, most boxers like maidana bloats up between fights and need to struggle to make weight, when the rehydrate the next day, the gain a lot of water.

All you do, is name calling, swearing profanity, and try to win a argument by stating have dumb the other person is.

Its the typical behavior of an unintelligent person, because the lack the skill and brain to debate in a sensible manner.

[brick wall]

lol...if only the ts's brain size was bigger