Anyone else had their scorecards closer to 117-111?

[heyhi1]

watched it three times......and i had it 8-4 mayweather everytime.

Same with me but there were close rounds that could of gone either way because mayweather was on the ropes blocking shots. 8-4 7-5 ...9-3 is stretching

[-PBP-]

Its possible. But you have to give Mayweather every close round in the fight.

[TintaBoricua]

watched it 4 times and i scored it the same, 9 - 3 Maidana.

*looks at sig*

Your opinion on scoring a Mayweather fight is as valid as trying to pass off a Snickers wrapper as a movie ticket.

If I was as bad as you scoring, I'd have Cotto winning the Trout fight 8-4.

[fighter1234]

First time I scored it I tried really hard to see Maidana winning rounds and had it 8-4 Mayweather. Second time I scored it, i watched neutrally and I found it hard to give Maidana more than 3 rounds. 9-3 maybe even 10-2 Mayweather. Maidana didn't really do anything except fight dirty. Take for instance the first round-one that most people thought was a clear Maidana round-pay close attention to what actually lands on the ropes. you'll see almost all of the clubbing hooks Maidana throws either slide through between Mayweather's gloves and face, or they hit him on the back of the head. Meanwhile Floyd is landing clean body punches during those exchanges that of course the commentators overlook. To be honest I only counted maybe 3 clean punches that actually landed on top of Floyd's forehead-not enough to win a round IMO.

[MaskedMurderer]

Nope only people who did are



or



or



everyone else saw

[pasawayako]

117-111 maidana.

[djtmal]

draw fight

[IIG]

9-3 or 8-4 are the most realistic scores in my view, and that's giving a ton of credit to Maidana. I'd much prefer a different challenger for September, but I guess a rematch wouldn't be the worst thing.

[rambov]

I don't think the fight was close at all. The Oscar fight was closer.

This was the ortiz fight that went on for 12 rounds

[spytactics]

I had it 7-5 for Maidana. I feel that he controlled the fight and floyd didnt do enough to squeeze out a win.