Is Maidana a P4P fighter?

[-MEGA-]

I'd say he cracks the top ten now.

[Da Machine]

Ehhh, it will never happen. He doesn't look the part.

That's just how it is in boxing.

I kind if want to see khan vs Maidana rematch. Let Floyd take a year off and let things build.

[The Problem Child]

He beat floyd last night convincingly and with sparring gloves, I mean, so without a doubt. I'd have to put him at #3 at the moment though. Pacquiao is still the best legit fighter in the game, he has no asterisks beside his wins and his resume speaks for itself. All Golovkin needs is names at this point and they're all avoiding him so. And then it's Maidana without a doubt.

1. Pacquiao 2. Golovkin 3. Maidana 4. Mayweather 5. Bradley

[Jsmooth9876]

I'd say he cracks the top ten now.

Why should Canelo be in there and not him at around 10.
Floyd
Manny
Ward
Bradley
Wald
JMM
Rigondeaux
Martinez
Then any of Garcia/Canelo/GGG/Maidana/

[Redd Foxx]

The Alexander fight wasn't that long ago and he damn near lost to SotoKaras. I'm not sold on P4P yet. But, I'm not ruling it out as he's proven he's getting better.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

No,,, he is close but I don't even think he is one of the top 3 guys at welter... I think porter would beat him...

Maidana is very proven and a good fighter, but just a notch below elite, but if someone had him on a list, I won't argue against it

[LoadedWraps]

I'd say he cracks the top ten now.

Without question.

[Kingjames6Flee]

He beat floyd last night convincingly and with sparring gloves, I mean, so without a doubt. I'd have to put him at #3 at the moment though. Pacquiao is still the best legit fighter in the game, he has no asterisks beside his wins and his resume speaks for itself. All Golovkin needs is names at this point and they're all avoiding him so. And then it's Maidana without a doubt.

1. Pacquiao 2. Golovkin 3. Maidana 4. Mayweather 5. Bradley

lmfao how the **** golovkin is second? you know you actually have to beat someone first.

[BigZigga]

I'd say so. I think he gives anyone at 147 hell

[IST-ra-GLEr2]

He's a "tough" ten fighter.