If someone beats Martinez/Pacquiao/Marquez....

[Mr.Fantastic]

Should those boxers get credit?

Martinez is rated #5 on the P4P list but hasn't looked spectacular as well as coming off surgery/injury.

Pacquiao #7 on the P4P list, according to everyone doesn't have that killer in him no more, got knocked out cold by Marquez and didn't look too great against Rios.

Marquez #6 on the P4P list, is coming off a loss vs Bradley and didn't look too great against him.


So any boxer that beats them should get credit right? They're P4P boxers and are rated at the top of the food chain.

[ImStillHere]

Yep everyone not named Floyd Mayweather would get credit

[Mr.Fantastic]

Yep everyone not named Floyd Mayweather would get credit

How is that so?

[Mr.Fantastic]

So tomorrow if Tim Bradley beats Pacquiao, he should get credit?

FYI, I'm going for Bradley yet again but think Pac is going to make resurface those demons he faced in the first fight.

[IST-ra-GLEr2]

Yes. A loss isn't the end all and be all of a resume.

Consistent ducking does more damage to a resume than a "good loss".