How did you score Garcia vs Herrera?

[sugarsmosley]

Lol thank god we never saw the mayweather fight. DANNY GARCIA got a gift and herrera was ROBBED!

[The Gambler1981]

I have beat this idea to death, but different judges like different things. Both guys clearly won 4 rounds, and the other 4 were extremely close. It is very conceivable that you scored all four of the rounds for the style you preferred whether that was Herrera's volume or Garcia's power. Remember boxing is subjective and in a fight with so many very close rounds there isn't necessarily a right or wrong in scoring. Clearly 2 of the judges liked what Garcia did in those rounds, the same with Adam. However It also makes since that the people scored it 116-112 for Herrera because they like his volume and boxing in those close rounds.

That is pretty much it, that is why I stopped scoring fight for the most part no one can ever accept that their way may not be the correct way, and a lot of it becomes group think and it just becomes pointless to even argue.


A way a fight can get scored should always be looked at as a range and in few fights does that range totally fall in one guys favor.

[DoktorSleepless]

This is one of the fights that proved once again how big of a joke compubox is.

[DondiNeverLeft]

I'm angry

[turkas]

That is pretty much it, that is why I stopped scoring fight for the most part no one can ever accept that their way may not be the correct way, and a lot of it becomes group think and it just becomes pointless to even argue.


A way a fight can get scored should always be looked at as a range and in few fights does that range totally fall in one guys favor.

Yep. It all comes down to the idea that different judges like different things and as long as it is a subjective scoring system people will get up set in close fights.

[kiaba360]

Herrera had a great performance all around. Seeing Garcia retreat in the 12th round

[Stark777]

Well almost everybody saw 7-5 or 8-4 Herrera, so it´s difficult to think that everybody is wrong.



I saw 8-4 Herrera, I am glad that I'm not blind yet.

[daggum]

Yep. It all comes down to the idea that different judges like different things and as long as it is a subjective scoring system people will get up set in close fights.

some judges like bribes and other judges don't. the judges that like bribes always get hired for some strange reason.

[mathed]

Garcia is done..he can't beat any viable opponent from here on out. Thurman, Peterson, Guerrero, Mayweather, Maidana...it's a wrap.

[kiaba360]

Garcia is done..he can't beat any viable opponent from here on out. Thurman, Peterson, Guerrero, Mayweather, Maidana...it's a wrap.

damn, he fell that far??? He did look a little drained before the fight, let's see how he looks at WW first.