Bigger legacy win for Mayweather....Martinez, Pacquiao, Hopkins, or Ward

[BoxingAddict773]

which one would be the biggest legacy wise.

Hopkins at 160
Pac at 147
Ward at 160
Martinez at 54, or 60

[Larry the boss]

which one would be the biggest legacy wise.

Hopkins at 160
Pac at 147
Ward at 160
Martinez at 54, or 60

Hopkins at 160=circus show meaningless

Pac at 147=good win
Ward at 160=circus show
Martinez at 154=pointless
Martinez at 160=lineal title win and a great win so there goes your answer

[Juof]

Obviously the pac fight

[boliodogs]

I think beating Pacquiao at 147 would be his biggest win.

[Fetta]

Lineal MW Champ!

[No bueno]

Hopkins at 160=circus show meaningless

Pac at 147=good win
Ward at 160=circus show
Martinez at 154=pointless
Martinez at 160=lineal title win and a great win so there goes your answer

Totally agree . Always thought and still hold out that Mayweather'd try and retire as not only undefeated but add the lineal middleweight title as the cherry a'top his career .

[hugh grant]

First things first, beating Pac at 147 would be his best win to date even a Pac not long coming off of a loss to JMM.

Im assuming if he beat Pac, he would then go on to fight Sergio. But he only dares go after Sergio because Miguel showed Floyd the way. And depending on how Miguel does.
Floyd never takes the initiative that's why he is not as great as he could be. Floiyd has to let someone he beat take the fight everyone wanted him to take.

get a move on Floyd, you had a long enough career break, and fighting only once every 18months, now is time to get down to business and stop dithering while everyone else jumps the queue for your opponents.

[BUNGALOWS]

I will never give Floyd for a Sergio fight, if Sergio has trouble with a fat ass Cotto.

Just like he always does. Waits for Sergio to look like ass and old, and then get another name on his resume, WAY TOO LATE.

[trainhard_187]

Mayweather beating Pacquiao at this point doesnt serve as much value as it would have pre Marquez KO...

Lets say they do fight and Floyd wins via UD or SD one or the other cause Floyd aint KOing Pacman, its like ok Floyd won but Marquez did what Floyd couldn't and those wars with JMM took alot of Pacman..

As of today I just wouldnt justify a Floyd win over Pac has high up there considering Pacman isnt the 08-12 Pacman, we would just be saying ok well he finally fought Pac and waited for the perfect time too..

My opinion..

[creekrat77]

I'd with out a doubt say Pacquiao because even if he beats him 2 years from now and its some what meaningless, it would be much more worst for his career if he didn't fight him at all. The Ward fight Mayweather would win an easy decision because that is a very awkward fight for Ward and Mayweather is a much better fighter. Hopkins is to old to claim a full credit win this day in age. Martinez I don't think is as great as a champion as some portay. If Mayweather was to pick between the three of these opponents then Pacquiao is the obvious pick for career defining wins. The others are yet to solidify they're legacy to the extent Pacquiao has.